A comparison of exemplar and statistical evidence in reducing counter‐arguments and responses to a message

A growing body of research indicates that both exemplar and statistical evidence are equally persuasive, but that persuasion is achieved differently due to the responses individuals have to these two forms of evidence. This study investigated the use of exemplars to reduce the generation of counterarguments and overall responses to a message compared to statistical evidence. Participants were exposed to a professionally produced 60 second videotaped public service announcement (PSA) on the dangers of tanning. As predicted, participants exposed to the PSA constructed with exemplar support produced significantly fewer counterarguments and fewer responses overall than those participants exposed to a PSA with statistical evidence. Additionally, there was no difference in the persuasive effect between evidence types, but both types of evidence were significantly more persuasive when compared to a control group.