Key result
Navigator HD shows no difference in ureteral injury risk versus Flexor but is easier to place.
Why the study?
The risk of ureteral wall injury associated with different ureteral access sheaths during ureteroscopy for stone disease was uncertain.
Does the Navigator HD sheath compared to the Flexor sheath reduce ureteral wall injury in patients undergoing ureteroscopy?
Does the Navigator HD sheath compared to the Flexor sheath reduce ureteral wall injury in patients undergoing ureteroscopy?
There is no significant difference in ureteral wall injury risk between Navigator HD and Flexor sheaths, though Navigator HD was rated subjectively easier to place.
May support trying Navigator after Flexor failure in ureteroscopy; leaves open optimal sheath selection pending RCTs.
crossed over to the other sheath for a trial of passage and excluded from video review.RESULTS: Patients had a mean cumulative stone diameter of 13.1Æ10.9mmand stone surface area burden of 1165Æ1065mm 2 .The success rate for initial sheath placement was 86.6%; placement rate and did not differ for sheaths groups.In no case did the Flexor sheath advance where the Navigator had failed while the Navigator was successful in passage in 50% (3/6) of the Flexor failures.The Navigator HD was subjectively rated as easier to place (3.4 vs 2.9, p¼0.029).Grade 1 injury was seen in 24.6%, grade 2 in 11.5% and grade 3 in 6.5%; there was no difference in rate of injury between sheaths.There were no grade 4 injuries.Male gender, large stone burden, longer time of sheath insertion and a more difficult subjective rating for sheath placement were associated with high grade (grade 2 or 3) ureteral injury.Postoperative complication rate was 11.1% and similar between zero/low and high grade injury groups.CONCLUSIONS: No significant difference in the risk of ureteral wall injury was noted between the two sheaths tested.Both a subjectively difficult sheath placement and a longer time of placement were associated with high grade injury, suggesting that surgeons should carry a low threshold for switching to a smaller sheath when resistance is felt.Though ureteral wall injury was not associated with any perioperative complications, long-term follow-up will be required to monitor for risk of stricture formation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Druskin et al. (2016) studied Ureteral stones. Navigator HD ureteral access sheath vs. Flexor ureteral access sheath was evaluated on Ureteral wall injury. There was no significant difference in the risk of ureteral wall injury between the Navigator HD and Flexor sheaths, though the Navigator HD was subjectively rated as easier to place (3.4 vs 2.9, p=0.029).
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: