Key result
School AED programs save an estimated 5 lives annually at substantial cost.
Why the study?
The cost-effectiveness of automated external defibrillator placement in Belgian schools was uncertain, limiting evidence-based policy decisions.
Is the placement of automated external defibrillators in Belgian schools cost-effective for saving lives from cardiac arrest?
Is the placement of automated external defibrillators in Belgian schools cost-effective for saving lives from cardiac arrest?
While feasible and effective, placing AEDs in all Belgian schools has a high cost per life saved due to the very low incidence of cardiac arrest in this setting.
Model estimates 5 annual lives saved at ~€4M cost in Belgian schools; leaves open value versus other interventions.
OBJECTIVE: Automated external defibrillators (AEDs) placed in public locations can save lives of cardiac arrest victims. In this paper, we try to estimate the cost-effectiveness of AED placement in Belgian schools. This would allow school policy makers to make an evidence-based decision about an on-site AED project. METHODS AND RESULTS: We developed a simple mathematical model containing literature data on the incidence of cardiac arrest with a shockable rhythm; the feasibility and effectiveness of defibrillation by on-site AEDs and the survival benefit. This was coupled to a rough estimation of the minimal costs to initiate an AED project. According to the model described above, AED projects in all Belgian schools may save 5 patients annually. A rough estimate of the minimal costs to initiate an AED project is 660 EUR per year. As there are about 6000 schools in Belgium, a national AED project in all schools would imply an annual cost of at least 3960 000 EUR, resulting in 5 lives saved. CONCLUSIONS: As our literature survey shows that AED use in schools is feasible and effective, the placement of these devices in all Belgian schools is undoubtedly to be considered. The major counter-arguments are the very low incidence and the high costs to set up a school-based AED programme. Our review may fuel the discussion about Whether or not school-based AED projects represent good value for money and should be preferred above other health care interventions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Cornelis et al. (2015) studied Cardiac arrest with a shockable rhythm. Automated external defibrillators (AEDs) placement in schools was evaluated on Lives saved and cost. A mathematical model estimated that placing automated external defibrillators in all 6,000 Belgian schools would cost at least 3,960,000 EUR annually and save 5 lives per year.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: