Key result
Playing music professionally evoked an average percent maximal heart rate of 59% during public performances and 52% during rehearsals, with genre type significantly affecting the response (p=0.01).
Why the study?
Does playing music professionally evoke physiological stress as indicated by heart rate response in professional musicians?
Observational (n=27)
Does playing music professionally evoke physiological stress as indicated by heart rate response in professional musicians?
Absolute Event Rate: 59% vs 52%
Playing music professionally evokes considerable increases in heart rate, which is significantly influenced by music genre, body mass index, tempo, and instrument type.
May warrant heart rate monitoring in musicians during performances; leaves open whether genre-specific factors alter long-term cardiovascular risk.
OBJECTIVES: The primary aim was to determine the level of physiological stress evoked while playing music in a standing position as indicated by heart rate (HR) response. A secondary aim was to analyze the effect of music genre (classic rock, western, contemporary Christian, and metal rock) on the relative HR response. Lastly, we considered potential physiological initiators of the music-playing-induced HR response. METHODS: HR response was monitored in 27 professional musicians (3 women, 24 men) between the ages of 21 and 67 yrs old during rehearsal and public performances. The percent maximal HR (%MHR) evoked was determined by taking a percentage of the age-predicted maximal HR for each musician and comparing the average %MHR in each genre during public and rehearsal events. The role of the potential initiators of these responses (e.g., number of years playing in public, event type, instrument type, tempo, etc.) was determined using multiple regression analyses. RESULTS: The overall average %MHR responses were 52 ± 5% and 59 ± 5% during rehearsal and public performances, respectively, with genre type having a significant effect on the HR response (p=0.01). Body mass index and tempo were each found to be significant contributors to the HR response while playing music (r²=0.506, p=0.001). CONCLUSION: Playing music professionally evokes considerable increases in HR response, with music genre influencing the level of the physiological response. We concluded that 50% of the HR response while playing music was associated with body mass index, music tempo, and instrument type.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Vellers et al. (2015) conducted an observational in Professional musicians (n=27). Public performance vs. Rehearsal was evaluated on Percent maximal heart rate (%MHR) evoked. Playing music professionally evoked an average percent maximal heart rate of 59% during public performances and 52% during rehearsals, with genre type significantly affecting the response (p=0.01).
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: