Changing-look active galactic nuclei (CL-AGN) have been proposed to follow an X-ray-binary-like, V-shaped relation between the optical/ultraviolet-to-X-ray spectral slope, αOX, and the Eddington ratio, λEdd ≡ Lbol/LEdd. We test this interpretation using CL-AGN selected from the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI) and control samples matched to the eROSITA all-sky survey (eRASS). We find that the apparent positive correlation between αOX and the optical-continuum-based Eddington ratio, λEdd, opt, is not unique to CL-AGN, but also appears in matched non-changing-look samples. In broad-Hα AGN, our main statistical sample, this structure is largely driven by the known dependence of αOX on ultraviolet luminosity and by the covariance between the rest-frame 2500 Å luminosity, L2500, the black-hole mass, MBH, and λEdd, opt. When an X-ray-based Eddington ratio is used instead, the relation reverses sign because the X-ray luminosity, LX, enters the two axes with opposite signs. An apparent αOX–Eddington-ratio V-shape can therefore be induced by the luminosity estimator and is not a standalone accretion-state diagnostic. As a complementary test, we examine the eRASS effective photon index, Γeff, inferred from catalogue band fluxes. In broad-line AGN, it shows a weak positive association with the X-ray-independent optical Eddington ratio. However, the weaker hard-band trend depends on the null model and does not isolate coronal softening. These results motivate further X-ray spectroscopy, combined with independently estimated Eddington ratios, to test for intrinsic changes in the disk–corona system.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Guo et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: