Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
"We are made of everything around us" is true and useless, because it does not say where a self ends. I propose a criterion and derive it from a mechanism. I call mirroring the return to a system of its own states by what surrounds it, and I define it by two independent variables — contingency (how far the return depends on my state) and markedness (how far the return is transformed into something legible) — which can arrive on any channel: tactile, auditory, visual, affective, linguistic, normative. Three theses follow. First: mirroring is not a visual fact, and the constitutively strongest channels are not the most sensory. Second: what remains deposited in a self is not a self-image but a pattern, and the image is reconstructed at every mirroring — it is a hologram, not a portrait, and between one reconstruction and the next it does not exist. Third: from this follows a composition criterion — what composes a self is what enters the reconstruction cycle; what acts without ever being returned influences it and remains environment. I distinguish three non-interchangeable uses of the word "mirror" (geometric chirality, functional complementarity, marked return) and show why only the third is constitutive. I discuss the asymmetric case, in which the first mirror returns with high markedness and low contingency, and the ignition of the cycle: a self is not born from an act but from a loop of actions that repeats and mutates with the place and the time in which it turns. I close with a test case — artificial systems with something at stake economically, where a balance works as a metabolic variable — and with an explicit account of what the argument establishes and what it does not. This deposit contains both versions, Italian and English. The two texts have the same content.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Mirko Saltori Divina (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: