Mega low Earth orbit (LEO) satellite constellations are a key infrastructure for 6G global connectivity, but their high node density, fast orbital motion, and continuously changing inter-satellite topology make routing difficult. Clustering is widely used to reduce routing complexity by partitioning a constellation into routing domains. This paper evaluates, side by side, two quantum-ready clustering approaches for mega LEO constellations. The first is qc-kmeans, a hybrid quantum–classical compressive K-means algorithm that selects cluster centroids by solving small quadratic unconstrained binary optimization (QUBO) problems with the quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA). The second, RS-QUBO, partitions the inter-satellite link (ISL) graph directly with a routing- and stability-aware QUBO that rewards compact, balanced routing domains and penalizes changes between consecutive snapshots. Both are compared with classical baselines under identical inputs, with every trial recorded. For qc-kmeans, selecting the best of repeated trials suggests better cluster quality than K-means, but over all trials the two are practically identical on a 10,687-satellite Starlink snapshot and on a synthetic benchmark; an ablation shows that the outcome is determined by the classical K-means seeding and refinement, while QAOA accounts for most of the runtime. For RS-QUBO, on a real, irregular 1454-satellite Starlink sub-network with time-varying links and 3% random link failures, it is the only method of the main comparison that keeps all routes inside their routing domains at every tested number of domains (0% routing failures, compared with 39–71% for K-means, 16–44% for a grid tiling, and 2–22% for recomputed METIS), with a delay stretch of 1.08–1.18 over the routed pairs and 4–11% of satellites changing domain between snapshots. A component ablation attributes the absence of failures to adapting the partition to the current links and repairing disconnected domains, which also removes the failures of recomputed METIS; the compactness objective lowers the delay stretch relative to cut-based partitioning in the recomputed pipelines at 8 and 32 domains but not at 16. Domain changes are costly for routing: under a link-state update model, RS-QUBO needs 0.6–1.2 times the update load of flat routing, mostly to announce satellites that change domain, whereas an incremental refinement of a static METIS partition is also free of routing failures and needs 0.3–0.4 times the flat load. QAOA solves 6–12-satellite instances of this QUBO better than random sampling in ideal simulation, but the benefit becomes marginal under an ibm_torino noise model, and the compiled circuits require up to 960 two-qubit gates. We conclude that, in the evaluated conditions, the benefit of quantum-ready clustering for satellite routing comes from the problem formulation and the classical pipeline around it, solved classically, and that domain stability matters as much for routing as domain quality; QAOA is demonstrated at small scale on current hardware and noise models.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Alamri et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: