The Pragmatic Approach to Masking

This paper advocates the use of a pragmatic approach to the problem of masking in real-life situations involving an abrupt change in the timing of sleep, i.e. shiftwork and "jet-lag" situations. Although "pure" chronobiological research has pointed to the importance of taking masking effects into account, the techniques that it has provided for doing so are extremely difficult to apply in real-life situations. The approach advocated here is based on Wever's pioneering work, and involves estimating the normative endogenous and exogenous components of the circadian rhythm in body temperature. These estimates are then used to: (a) simulate the results of shiftwork studies; and (b) to "remove" the exogenous component in "jet-lag" studies to allow analysis of the estimated endogenous component. The simulated curves obtained cross-correlated extremely highly with published night-shift temperature curves, while the "removal" of the exogenous component resulted in very similar findings to those obtained in temporal isolation studies. It is concluded that this pragmatic approach to masking may prove extremely useful in interpreting the results of field studies of shiftwork and "jet-lag".