Hypertrophic cardiomyopathy mutations Y115H and E497D disrupt the folded-back state of human beta-cardiac myosin allosterically

At the molecular level, clinical hypercontractility associated with many hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM)-causing mutations in beta-cardiac myosin appears to be driven by their disruptive effect on the energy-conserving, folded-back, super relaxed (SRX) OFF-state of myosin. A pathological increase in force production results from release of heads from this OFF-state, which results in an increase in the number of heads free to interact with actin and produce force. Pathogenic mutations in myosin can conceivably disrupt the OFF-state by (1) directly affecting the intramolecular interfaces stabilizing the folded-back state, or (2) allosterically destabilizing the folded-back state via disruption of diverse conformational states of the myosin motor along its chemomechanical cycle. However, very little is understood about the mutations that fall in the latter group. Here, using recombinant human beta-cardiac myosin, we analysed the biomechanical properties of two such HCM-causing mutations, Y115H (in the transducer) and E497D (in the relay helix), neither of which falls in the regions that interact to stabilize the myosin folded-back state. We find these mutations have diverse effects on the contractility parameters of myosin, yet the primary hypercontractile change in both cases is the destabilization of the OFF-state of myosin and increased availability of active myosin heads for actin-binding. Experimental data and molecular dynamics simulations indicate that these mutations likely destabilize the pre-powerstroke state of myosin, the conformation the motor adopts in the inactive folded-back state. We propose that destabilization of the folded-back state of myosin, directly and/or allosterically, is the molecular basis of hypercontractility in HCM in a far greater number of pathogenic mutations than currently thought.