What question did this study set out to answer?

The central aim is to analyze the compatibility and tensions between Trama Epistemológica and the Theory of Objectivity.

June 22, 2026Open Access

EPISTEMOLOGICAL WEAVE AND MODAL DISCIPLINE: methodological plurality, epistemic subjectivity, and transcendent knowledge in critical-propositional dialogue with the Theory of Objectivity

Key Points

The central aim is to analyze the compatibility and tensions between Trama Epistemológica and the Theory of Objectivity.
Conducted a critical-propositional analysis of the article by Rozeira and Silva.
Focused on themes such as scientific method, epistemology, and methodological plurality.
Utilized analytical support from ChatGPT for deeper exploration of concepts.
Identified compatibility between the analyzed article and Theory of Objectivity, particularly in complexity and methodological openness.
Highlighted tensions around flexibility and subjectivity in the article versus TO's requirements for logical coherence and testability.
Concluded that Trama Epistemológica contributes to TO, emphasizing the need for empirical bridges within modal discipline.

Abstract

This article presents a critical-propositional analysis of Trama Epistemológica: Entretecendo o Conhecimento Científico, by Carlos Henrique Barbosa Rozeira, Carlos Felipe Barbosa Rozeira, and Marcos Fernandes da Silva, published on Zenodo under DOI https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.10002060, in dialogue with the Theory of Objectivity (TO). The study examines the article’s treatment of scientific method, epistemology, subjectivity, methodological plurality, interdisciplinarity, and complexity. It argues that the analyzed text does not offer a cosmological model, a modal demonstration, or an empirical test directly applicable to TO. Nevertheless, it provides relevant epistemological support for the TO research program, especially by clarifying how broad, non-conventional, and interdisciplinary theories may be formulated, evaluated, criticized, and communicated. The analysis identifies strong compatibility between the article and TO in the fields of complexity, methodological openness, interdisciplinarity, and the relational understanding of knowledge. At the same time, it highlights important tensions: while the analyzed article emphasizes flexibility, subjectivity, and plurality, TO requires modal necessity, logical coherence, ontological discipline, and operational testability. The article concludes that Trama Epistemológica may function as an indirect epistemological contribution to the Theory of Objectivity, provided that methodological openness remains subordinated to modal discipline and to the construction of empirical bridges. This analytical study was developed with analytical support from ChatGPT. Keywords: Theory of Objectivity; Vidamor Cabannas; Denivaldo Silva; epistemology; scientific method; methodological plurality; subjectivity; complexity; interdisciplinarity; modal discipline; scientific knowledge; Inducer Effects; phenomenic elements; transcendent knowledge; ChatGPT-assisted analysis.

EPISTEMOLOGICAL WEAVE AND MODAL DISCIPLINE: methodological plurality, epistemic subjectivity, and transcendent knowledge in critical-propositional dialogue with the Theory of Objectivity

Key Points

Abstract

Cite This Study

Also Consider

Also Consider