What question did this study set out to answer?

The aim is to highlight the importance of deep understanding in the peer review process.

July 4, 2026Open Access

Trail Stop 3: Reading Like a Reviewer

CNChristina M. NyiratiUniversity of Bahrain

Key Points

The aim is to highlight the importance of deep understanding in the peer review process.
Emphasized the need for analytical and constructive skills in reviewing.
Discussed balancing attention to details with appreciation for broader concepts.
Outlined the impact of organized feedback on editors and authors.
Effective peer reviewers contribute to enhancing the quality of scholarly work.
Thoughtful feedback helps manuscripts fulfill their intended purpose.
A deeper understanding of articles leads to more constructive critiques.

Abstract

Christina M. Nyirati emphasizes that becoming an excellent peer reviewer involves shifting focus from mere reading to deep understanding of a manuscript's purpose and contribution. Effective reviewing requires analytical and constructive skills, balancing attention to details with an appreciation for broader concepts. Thoughtful, organized feedback aids both editors and authors in enhancing scholarly work.

KI fragen

Bookmark

View Full Paper