Treadmill testing in 410 normal subjects showed the cardiac chronotropic response follows a linear function (%HRR = 0.95 × %MR + 3.4 for Bruce protocol), independent of the exercise protocol.
Observational (n=410)
The normal cardiac chronotropic response to exercise can be accurately modeled as a simple linear mathematical function independent of the treadmill protocol used.
A mathematical model was developed from data collected from 410 normal subjects in order to describe the normal cardiac Chronotropic response to exercise. Subjects were examined by treadmill testing on either the Bruce protocol (189 patients) or the Chronotropic Assessment Exercise Protocol (CAEP) (221 patients), The CAEP, designed specifically for chronotropic assessment, is structured to collect heart rate data at submaximal as well as peak exercise intensities. Analysis of these subjects, without evidence of medical illness or cardiac medications, found the heart rate response to be a function of exercise intensity, age, resting heart rate, and maximal functional capacity. Heart rate reserve (HRR) was defined as the difference betii'een maximal predicted heart rate (MPHR) and resting heart (HR rest ). Metabolic reserve was defined as the difference between the maximally achieved workload (METS peak ) and the workload at rest (METS rest ). The Bruce and CAEP data provided a statistically linear and identical response of the form y = mx + b. The Bruce equation was %HRR = 0.95 ×%MR + 3.4 and the CAEP equation is %HRR = 0.94 ×%MR + 4.55. The following formula describes the normal predicted heart rate for an individual at some submaximal stage of exercise: HR stage = (220 ‐ age ‐HR rest ) × (METS stage ‐ 1)/(METS peak ‐ 1) + HR rest . We conclude that the cardiac chronotropic response can be modeled as a simple linear mathematical function of exercise intensity, age, resting heart rate, and maximal functional capacity, and is independent of type of treadmill exercise protocol in normal subjects.
Wilkoff et al. (Thu,) conducted a observational in Normal subjects (n=410). Treadmill testing was evaluated on Cardiac chronotropic response to exercise. Treadmill testing in 410 normal subjects showed the cardiac chronotropic response follows a linear function (%HRR = 0.95 × %MR + 3.4 for Bruce protocol), independent of the exercise protocol.