We report the results of PHILIA Phase SC-9b, a pre-registered confirmatory analysis and integrated remeasurement superseding SC-8 (73rd DOI: 10. 5281/zenodo. 20621215) and SC-9a (75th DOI: 10. 5281/zenodo. 20667352) for all synthetic-family analyses generated prior to the Cycle 17 prep-standard lock. SC-9b applies the locked v32 self-raw × 3-channel normalization apparatus with the prep-standard generator (philiaₛc8ₛyntheticₚrep. py) to n=182 substrates across four families (RealWorld n=90, Synthetic n=44, Physics n=18, Financial n=30) under independent seeds 77–81 (T=80, 000; 910 total runs, 910 successful). Three pre-registered hypotheses were tested (αₚer=0. 05 each; Pre-registration v0. 2 §3. 6 statistical independence rationale): H-SC9b-Primary (AC1 7-strata binary monotonicity, 6/6 MW U one-tailed): NOT CONFIRMED. 0/6 adjacent pairs passed; Spearman ρ (strataᵢdx, meanᵦ) =−0. 857, p=0. 014. Cause: substrate-class-conditional AC1 modulation across heterogeneous family composition. H-SC9b-Secondary (AR vs Chaos OLS interaction β₄ (AC1×class) >0): NOT CONFIRMED. β₄=−0. 0755, pₒne=0. 776, partial η²=0. 017 (small effect). VIF (class) =58. 15 confirms quasi-multicollinearity (L-7 NEW permanently confirmed). H-SC9b-Tertiary (Traffic+Environment ρ (MSE, z) ≥+0. 85, 4th replication): NOT CONFIRMED. ρ=+0. 8492 (Δ=0. 0008 below threshold) ; pₒne<10⁻⁹. All four independent replications (SC-7 through SC-9b) yield ρ∈+0. 849, +0. 875. Key exploratory findings: E-2 AR (1) φ-sweep ρ=−0. 9856 (4th independent replication, strongest result to date; SC-2: −0. 9636, SC-8: −0. 9711, SC-9a: −0. 9752). E-4 substrate-class-conditional AC1 modulation raw-confirmed: Synthetic/AR ρ (AC1, z) =−0. 984, RealWorld=−0. 334, Synthetic/Chaos=−0. 092 — three qualitatively distinct mechanisms. E-5 AR conjoint redundancy ρ (AC1, MSE) =−0. 9684 RE-CONFIRMED. E-1 4-family Cochran's Q=6. 12, p=0. 106 (Homogeneous; heterogeneity progressively decreasing from SC-8). The cumulative evidence now favors substrate-class-specific modulation over a universal AC1 monotonicity law. Zero pre-registration violations. 3-tier SHA256 chain-of-custody verified (Registry: 3948b551…; Measure: 7ad1fc37…; Confirmatory: 41dfe074…). 5-AI adversarial review pipeline: Seonbi (Claude Sonnet), Chris (Claude Opus, Gate-0 v10 Cycle 31 UNCONDITIONAL ACCEPT), Pandora (ChatGPT), Lucas (Grok), Seogsaeng (Gemini). Pre-registration DOI: 10. 5281/zenodo. 20676046Trinity AI Research Team | Konyang University | June 2026Measurement is life. Description, not proof. — PHILIA OS | 0∞1∞0. 5∞
신두섭 (Sun,) studied this question.