What question did this study set out to answer?

This case study aimed to demonstrate how integrating greenness and whiteness metrics can enhance decision-making in pharmaceutical quality control.

June 20, 2026Open Access

Integrating Sustainability Metrics Into Analytical Decision-Making in Biopharmaceutical Quality Control: An Industrial Case Study

Key Points

This case study aimed to demonstrate how integrating greenness and whiteness metrics can enhance decision-making in pharmaceutical quality control.
Compared non-aqueous potentiometric titrations (PT) with spectrofluorimetric methods (SFM) for aromatic amino acid assays.
Applied the Advanced National Environmental Methods Index, Analytical Eco-Scale, Green Analytical Procedure Index, and Analytical GREEnness metric for sustainability assessment.
Utilized White Analytical Chemistry to combine analytical performance with sustainability and operational feasibility.
SFM was preferred, indicating lower environmental impact with a higher Eco-Scale score of 93 compared to PT's 76.
AGREE scores showed SFM at 0.61 versus PT at 0.34, highlighting better sustainability metrics.
WAC scores indicated SFM at 81.3 while PT scored only 65.5, confirming SFM as the environmentally and practically superior method.

Abstract

Abstract Purpose Analytical methods of pharmaceutical quality control (QC) are typically selected for regulatory compliance and analytical performance, while sustainability and operational feasibility are often secondary. This case study aimed to demonstrate how combining greenness and whiteness metrics can support method-related decisions in QC under batch practice. Methods Compendial non-aqueous potentiometric titrations (PT) for aromatic amino acids used as raw materials were compared with alternatives spectrofluorimetric methods (SFM) developed for assays. The Advanced National Environmental Methods Index (advanced NEMI) was applied during development as an early screening tool, followed by the Analytical Eco-Scale and Green Analytical Procedure Index (GAPI), and Analytical GREEnness metric (AGREE) to quantify and localize environmental burdens under finalized conditions. Finally, White Analytical Chemistry (WAC) was employed to integrate analytical performance, environmental impact, and implementation practicality. Results Across these tools, PT was penalized by corrosive non-aqueous chemistry and higher hazardous reagent and waste demands, implying greater safety controls and waste-handling effort at scale. Triangulation converged on the same decision signal: SFM remained fit for release testing while reducing hazardous touchpoints and simplifying waste logistics, yielding superior greenness indicators (Eco-Scale: 93 vs. 76; AGREE: 0.61 vs. 0.34) and a higher WAC score (81.3 vs. 65.5). Conclusion Overall, the metric set shifted the basis from “analytically compliant” to “fit for deployment,” framed by a Six Sigma improvement logic (Define–Measure–Analyze–Improve–Control), thereby strengthening sustainability-informed analytical development and change-control decisions in industrial QC.

Demander à l'IA

Bookmark

View Full Paper