Contradictory task demands among junior physicians during post-graduate training: An explorative, multi-methods study

Introduction: Junior physicians often face high levels of work stress, burnout, and depression, largely due to challenging work conditions. Contradictory task demands, a specific job stressor where junior physicians are expected to fulfill conflicting goals simultaneously, have received limited attention, but may significantly impact their mental health and job satisfaction. Objective: This study aimed to identify key contradictory demands faced by junior physicians in specialty training and examine associations with physician health and well-being. Methods: Step-wise and multi-methods procedure comprising explorative interviews and standardized surveys. A convenience sample of junior physicians undergoing specialty training in Germany were surveyed. Thematic analyses of qualitative data as well as descriptive and bivariate analyses were performed. Results: Drawing upon seven in depth interviews, experiences of key contradictory demands were extracted and consolidated into 19 distinct statements. 28 Survey responses were obtained with the highest ratings for "Non-physician activities, additional tasks versus Focus on core clinical tasks" as well as "General workload versus Regular working time". Associations with physician health and well-being outcomes were moderate and inconsistent. Discussion: Preliminary results shed light on experiences of contradictory task demands in clinical work among junior physicians. A broad spectrum of potentially incompatible or conflicting demands on the job was observed. The findings underscore the complexity of the clinical work environment, where multiple conflicting demands create a particularly challenging educational and work setting for junior physicians. The results may inform tailored approaches to mitigate work stress in this professional group.