Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Analysis reveals R2 errors significantly affect paramagnetic and diamagnetic outputs in susceptibility source separation, indicating the need for meticulous R2 accuracy.
To examine the importance of R2 accuracy on independent paramagnetic and diamagnetic outputs from susceptibility source separation in the brain from two publicly available methods. The effects of R2 errors, which translate into R2'R₂ errors, on output maps from χ-separation and χ-sepnet were examined using data from 11 healthy volunteers. Baseline R2 values were determined by Bloch modeling a dual-echo turbo spin echo decay with measured flip angles. R2 errors were introduced from either simple exponential fitting, R2 multiplication factors, or R2 approximation using only R2*R₂ . Altered R2 maps were then used as input for the susceptibility source separation models using either default or calculated relaxometric constant. Difference maps and mean percentage errors within regions of interest (ROIs) were measured. Errors in R2, and hence R2'R₂ , directly affected paramagnetic and diamagnetic components. χ-sepnet was less sensitive to R2 errors than χ-separation and had reduced variance among subjects. χ-sepnet susceptibility component errors did not reach more than ±20% in most ROIs for all alteration approaches. In contrast, χ-separation, with default relaxometric constant, reached 56% susceptibility component error with -25% R2 error input. Exponential fitting R2 error exceeded -25%, thus, even larger component errors occurred. R2*R₂ -based approximation had -25% R2 mean error across ROIs (-18% across whole brain), yielding 57% mean susceptibility component error across ROIs. Paramagnetic and diamagnetic outputs of susceptibility source separation methods have variable responses to R2 error, that may occur with simple R2 fitting or R2 approximation, and can be strongly biased by it.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Assunção et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: