Biotinylation Interferes with Protein Ubiquitylation and Turnover in Arabidopsis—A Cautionary Insight for Proximity Labeling in Ubiquitylation Proteome Studies

Nearly all eukaryotic proteins are turned over by the ubiquitin (Ub)-26S proteasome system (UPS). Despite its broad cellular roles, only a handful of UPS members, particularly the Ub E3 ligases that specifically recognize a protein for ubiquitylation, have been characterized in plants to date. The challenge arises from the transient recognition and rapid degradation of ubiquitylation substrates by the UPS. To tackle this challenge, the emerging biotinylation-based proximity labeling (PL) offers an exciting tool for enriching transient interactors of Ub E3 ligases. In this study, we examined the efficacy of TurboID in identifying substrates of Arabidopsis Skp1-cullin1-F-box (SCF) ligases. We demonstrate that the Arabidopsis Skp1 Like (ASK)1-TurboID is not fully functioning in planta, which led us to discover a novel antagonism between biotinylation and ubiquitylation in regulating protein stability in vivo. This discovery lowers the effectiveness of PL in ubiquitylome studies. However, using one long-known SCF substrate, phytochrome A, we succeeded to apply its TurboID fusion for complementing the far-red-light response of the phyA-211 null mutant allele, suggesting an efficacy of PL in characterizing single ubiquitylation pathways. This study highlighted a limitation of PL in ubiquitylome studies, discovered a new antagonistic pathway of biotinylation, and developed a theoretical guidance for future PL-based characterization of ubiquitylation pathways.