Empirical Research to Design Rule-Based Strategy Control with Energy Consumption Minimization Strategy of Energy Management Systems in Hybrid Electric Propulsion Systems

Equivalent energy consumption minimization methods of energy management systems have been implemented as a rule-based strategy to enhance electric propulsion system efficiency. This study compares the efficiencies of different systems by applying variable- and constant-speed generators with battery hybrid systems, measuring fuel consumption. In the same scenario, the variable-speed operation showed a notable improvement of 10.36% compared to the conventional system. However, in the verification of hybrid system efficiency, onshore charged energy cannot be considered a reduction in fuel consumption. Instead, when converting onshore energy usage into equivalent fuel consumption for comparative analysis, both hybrid constant- and variable-speed operation modes achieved efficiency enhancements ranging from 5.5% to 9.79% compared to the conventional, nonequivalent constant-speed operation mode. Conversely, the nonequivalent variable-speed operation mode demonstrated an efficiency that was 5.41% higher than that of the hybrid constant-speed operation mode. In contrast, the battery-integrated variable-speed operation mode indicated a system efficiency approximately equal to that of the nonequivalent variable-speed operation mode. For vessels with load profiles characterized by prolonged periods of idling or low-load operations, a battery-integrated hybrid system could be a practical solution. This study demonstrates the necessity of analyzing load profiles, even when aiming for the optimal operational set points of the generator engine.