During the sudden closure of gates in long-distance gravity flow water supply projects, intense water hammer waves are generated. These waves can cause severe damage to the water supply tunnel structure, posing a significant threat to project safety. To develop an economical and effective hydraulic safety control strategy, this study uses the example of a specific gravity flow water supply project with long-distance and multi-fluctuation pressure tunnels in Zhejiang Province. A novel combined protection strategy was investigated, involving the conversion of construction branch tunnels into branch tunnel surge tanks combined with an overflow surge tank. Numerical simulations of gate closure-induced water hammer pressures were conducted using the method of characteristics. Additionally, the effectiveness of the overflow surge tank on controlling the surge water level in the branch tunnels was analyzed with respect to variations in its height, diameter, and impedance hole diameter. The results indicate that a 300 s linear gate closure without any protective measures induces severe water hammer pressure. Extending the closure time to 1200 s still results in pressures far exceeding the safety threshold. Converting construction branch tunnels into surge tanks effectively controlled the water hammer pressure; however, overflow issues emerged in some branch tunnels. The subsequent addition of an overflow surge tank at the end of the water supply system successfully eliminated the risk of overflow in the branch tunnels. Building upon this, multi-parameter optimization analysis was used to determine the optimal configuration for the overflow surge tank. This solution ensures hydraulic safety while maintaining cost-effectiveness. Both the maximum pressure and the minimum pressure along the water supply tunnel, as well as the surge water levels in all branch tunnels, meet the code requirements. Furthermore, the reduced size of the surge tank significantly lowered construction costs. The findings of this research provide theoretical foundations and technical support for similar long-distance gravity flow water supply projects.
Mao et al. (Fri,) studied this question.