An Integrated Delphi-AHP Study on the Systematic Improvement of Sea Anchors for Fishing Operations

Sea anchors for fishing operations are essential equipment to enhance catch efficiency and ensure operational stability at sea. However, previous studies have mainly focused on theoretical modeling or experiments under restricted conditions, which have not sufficiently reflected the complex operating environments and practical needs of real-world fisheries. To address this gap, this study derived key factors to improve the design and operation of sea anchors and quantitatively analyze the relative importance and rank of these factors. An expert panel was formed from 25 participants, including jigging vessel captains, recreational fishing boat captains, sea anchor manufacturers, and research institute workers. Using a three-round Delphi process followed by Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) analysis, we distilled an initial list of 52 improvement suggestions into 15 prioritized items, quantitatively ranked by relative importance based on expert consensus. The highest-ranked factor was ‘Enhancement of fabric drying performance’, followed by ‘Application of low-cost, high-efficiency materials’, ‘Improvement of recovery’, ‘Enhancement of UV resistance’, and ‘Product quality certification’. The highest-weighted metric was ‘Improvement of usability’, followed by ‘Enhanced durability’ and ‘Improvement of functionality’. The consistency ratio (CR) of the pairwise-comparison matrix was 0.0014 (AHP acceptability criterion: CR ≤ 0.1), confirming the reliability and consistency of the analysis. By reflecting real-world priorities through a robust and systematic analytical process, this study offers a foundation for evidence-based improvements in sea anchor design and operation, overcoming the limitations of earlier approaches rooted in subjective judgment or trial-and-error experience.