Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Survey reveals only 7% discuss cognitive risks in surgery, suggesting a need for improved patient education on brain health.
We are living in an era the United Nations has proclaimed "The Decade of Healthy Aging" [1]. The World Health Organization adopted a 2022–2031 intersectoral global action plan that envisages a "world in which brain health is valued, promoted, and protected across the life course; neurological disorders are avoided; and people affected by neurological disorders and their carers attain the highest possible level of health, with equal rights, opportunities, respect and autonomy" [2]. In this era of global attention to brain health, Canales and co-authors highlight a striking blind spot in geriatric perioperative care. They surveyed a large sample of older adults undergoing elective surgery and found that only 7% reported preoperative discussion with their health care providers about cognitive risks associated with surgery [3]. In follow-up interviews with people who experienced cognitive changes after surgery, they found that 90% did attempt to discuss their symptoms with a healthcare provider. Yet, none received counseling or guidance on how to manage or improve their cognitive symptoms. Instead, they were advised to wait and see if symptoms persisted. This pattern represents a missed opportunity to promote active recovery, encourage healthy lifestyle behaviors, and protect the long-term brain health of older adults. Surgery can be life-extending, but if it accelerates or unmasks cognitive decline without empowering patients with the knowledge or tools they need for proactive management, then it risks undermining the very autonomy and quality of life that medical interventions aim to preserve. Informed consent is not simply a legal formality; it is an ethical process that protects autonomy and builds trust. For older adults, especially those facing major surgery, autonomy extends beyond the right to say yes or no—it includes the right to understand the full spectrum of risks and benefits, including cognitive risks that affect identity, independence, and quality of life. The American College of Surgeons National Surgical Quality Improvement Program, the American Geriatric Society Best Practices Guidelines, and the International Perioperative Neurotoxicity Working Group all recommend assessing cognitive ability for any patient older than 65 years to assess the risk of post-operative cognitive dysfunction [4, 5]. This process not only highlights the risk of perioperative neurocognitive disorder (PND) but also offers older adults the opportunity to consider their values and preferences around brain health. It can provide them with the awareness and vocabulary to self-monitor and report perioperative cognitive changes. Evidence consistently shows that patient education and self-efficacy are associated with improved surgical outcomes [6]. In the perioperative setting, structured education has been shown to reduce anxiety, improve pain management, and enhance recovery [7]. Shared decision-making involves conversations around patient preferences and values, which is critical during elective surgery, particularly for older adults who are at greater risk for harm and decisional regret [8]. Yet, surgeons acknowledge a predominant focus on risk metrics rather than individual patient preferences in older adult pre-surgical planning [9]. The need for language translation in patients who do not speak English may serve as an additional barrier to shared decision-making. Canary and colleagues show that a small percentage of English-speaking patients did recall cognitive risk–benefit discussions with their healthcare providers; however, none of the non-English speakers recalled this type of discussion. Language barriers compound existing vulnerabilities, leaving large groups of patients without the knowledge and tools to protect their brain health. Provision of translation services and accessible educational materials will ensure equitable advancement of perioperative care for all patients. Physical prehabilitation is now widely recognized as beneficial before surgery; it improves mobility, cardiopulmonary reserve, and reduces complications [10]. Cognitive prehabilitation should be similarly considered as a routine option for high-risk patients in perioperative care. Emerging literature supports this approach. In a randomized controlled trial, older adults who engaged in structured cognitive training before surgery experienced lower rates of postoperative cognitive dysfunction [11]. Additional trials are underway [12, 13]. Even simple strategies, such as visual orientation cues, memory checklists, or engaging in cognitively stimulating activities, can help patients feel empowered to monitor, protect, and even enhance their own brain health. Moreover, prehabilitation fosters a sense of agency. Instead of being passive recipients of surgical risks, patients become active participants in their recovery. This not only strengthens self-efficacy but may also reduce anxiety and improve overall satisfaction with care. Cognitive recovery after surgery is not linear. It is a dynamic process shaped by multiple interacting systems: the brain's resilience, the burden of comorbidities, perioperative insults (e.g., inflammation, hypoxia), and post-discharge environmental supports. Dynamic systems modeling offers a useful lens [14]. It conceptualizes recovery as a trajectory influenced by both baseline vulnerability (predisposing factors), perioperative complications (precipitating factors), and continuous post-operative inputs (perpetuating factors). A small perturbation—such as an episode of delirium—can push an older adult into a downward spiral if unaddressed, while proactive interventions (early mobilization, hydration, sleep hygiene, social engagement) can nudge the trajectory back toward recovery. Brain health is not static; it can be strengthened or depleted. Patients need to be reassured that a post-operative dip in vitality does not mean an inevitable decline to frailty. Evidence-based lifestyle factors known to reduce dementia risk, such as regular physical activity, Mediterranean-style diets, cognitive enrichment, social connection, and sleep optimization, are equally relevant in the perioperative context [15, 16]. When physicians frame these interventions not just as long-term health advice but as part of the surgical recovery toolkit, patients can envision tangible steps to protect and rebuild their cognitive vitality and reserve. In this sense, perioperative care should not be about waiting to see if symptoms persist. It should be about active, dynamic management of brain health during a vulnerable period. For many older adults, the brain is not just another organ; it is the seat of identity, autonomy, and dignity. Older adults often value quality of life and independence over physical longevity [17]. We have learned from Canales et al. that older adults' preferences around cognitive outcomes are rarely elicited. This raises the concern that many older adults may be denied the opportunity to make informed choices about what matters most to them. True respect for autonomy requires more than presenting the standard physical risks; it requires asking patients what outcomes they value most and aligning perioperative care with their priorities. For some, preserving cognitive health may outweigh the risks of physical decline. For others, the opposite may be true. But all must be given the choice and the tools to act on it, such as education, cognitive prehabilitation, and lifestyle-based brain health strategies. Respecting autonomy means partnering with patients to actively safeguard what they value: their independence, memory, and sense of self. If we succeed, we may transform surgery from a threat to the aging brain into an opportunity to reinforce its health and resilience (Figure 1). K.B. wrote the manuscript. Funding supported investigator time, but not this project directly. The views expressed represent those of the author's and not that of the sponsor's. The author declares no conflicts of interest. This publication is linked to related article by Canales et al. To view this article visit https://doi.org/10.1111/jgs.70063.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Karen Blackmon (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: