Umbrella review identifies 172 features of voice content and topography in psychosis, suggesting improved CBT approaches.
Background Auditory verbal hallucinations (‘voices’) in clinical psychosis are associated with significant distress and disability, but the efficacy of CBT for voices is modest. Greater phenomenological understanding is crucial for the development of theoretical models and more tailored CBT interventions. Aim This work aimed to produce an evidence‐based empirical framework of features of voice content and topography in adult psychosis. Method Electronic databases, journal pages and book publishers were systematically searched. Identified reviews were screened against inclusion criteria and included reviews critically appraised. Study characteristics and data relating to voice content/topography were extracted and collated. Results Forty‐two reviews were identified. A framework of 172 features of voice content and topography was produced. Conclusions This paper offers the most comprehensive evidence‐based dissection of voice content and topography to date. Many features have been overlooked and should be tested for theoretical and clinical significance in order to further develop CBT and related interventions for voices.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Callahan et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: