Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Using UK-Huawei 5G as a case, this paper maps the securitisation dynamics in the co-occurrence of (de)politicisation. Drawing links between macro/niche-securitisation and (de)politicisation, this paper argues that macro-securitisation can potentially politicise an issue whereas niche-securitisation can potentially depoliticise it. This analysis focuses on the 'concern-solution' framing within UK parliamentary debates on Huawei 5G from 2019 to 2020, examining the security narratives of both parliamentarians and ministers. Although both groups addressed national security concerns, parliamentarians macro-securitised Huawei 5G by highlighting the 'Huawei-China' linkage and framing it as an 'Us-Them' identity issue, portraying it as a threat to the UK's ideology, values and identity. In contrast, ministers employed niche-securitisation, confining the issue to the telecoms sector and emphasising the overall networks rather than singling out Huawei or China. The parliamentarians' macro-securitisation potentially rendered Huawei 5G louder and noisier, leading to calls for an outright ban and stricter legislation. Conversely, the government's niche-securitisation potentially shifted focus towards diversifying the telecoms supply chain, thereby discursively delegating this issue to experts and market and legitimising its abnormal decision-makings on Huawei 5G.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sun et al. (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: