Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
We read the letter by Rudler and colleagues in reference to our study on recurrent alcohol-associated hepatitis (AH) and would like to comment on some of the issues raised. Regarding noninvasive diagnostic criteria of AH, it has been consistently shown that their accuracy is not higher than 80%. We recently proposed new criteria,1 which were validated in the study cited by Rudler and colleagues. Nevertheless, performing a liver biopsy in this setting is not standard practice as per clinical practice guidelines. Our study on recurrent AH is a multicenter analysis with a pragmatic design in which most centers did not have transjugular biopsy available. Inclusion criteria were based on NIAAA Consortium recommendations and were consistent with previous studies in the field. With regard to the indication for preemptive TIPS (pTIPS), several comments are needed. First, it should be noted that the applicability of pTIPS in AH is low: in our study, only 23 patients (2% of the cohort and 32% of those bleeding) were candidates according to current criteria. Second, evidence on the efficacy and safety of pTIPS in AH is lacking: previous trials do not provide data on the number of patients with AH enrolled but mean bilirubin levels are well below the diagnostic cutoff for AH, suggesting that very few patients with AH were enrolled.2 Consequently, conclusions on the applicability of pTIPS should be taken with caution when applied to AH. Third, AH has a specific natural history and distinct HVPG dynamics compared to decompensated cirrhosis: following an episode of AH, abstinent patients and those occasionally consuming often achieve a spontaneous reduction in HVPG of more than 20%,3 thus reducing their risk of recurrent bleeding and death.4 In contrast to the weak evidence of pTIPS in AH, many studies have shown that alcohol abstinence is the most important prognostic factor across all stages of alcohol-associated liver disease.5 In our opinion, TIPS should be used with caution in AH until specific information becomes available. Conversely, we believe efforts should be directed toward the treatment of alcohol use disorder.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gratacós‐Ginès et al. (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: