Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
When a minor child commits a tort and certain damages are caused to the victim, who should bear the resulting damages? It would be natural under the principle of fault liability that the minor who is a party to the tort should also bear the resulting liability, but there are cases in which the minor lacks the capacity to be responsible due to age or judgment (a problem of requirement), and there are cases in which the victim lacks the capacity to pay, which is not sufficient for the victim's relief (a problem of effect). The Decision of the Korean Supreme Court delivered on April 14, 2022 has decided for the first time that non-custodial parents of minor do not bear supervision and supervisor liability for the tort of minor in principle, but only bear liability for damages caused by supervision in exceptional cases, and it has been pointed out that there are problems with the Supreme Court’s decision in terms of the rights and obligations of non-custodial parents and in terms of the relief and protection of victims. Therefore, this article has examined the issues of non-custodial parents’ duty of supervision and supervisor liability for the torts of their minor children, focusing on the Decision, and found the following points: Parental supervision and parental liability for damages to victims of their minor’s torts are predicated on legal obligations, and parental supervision and liability for damages are recognized because a parent is a person who can directly influence the behavior of a child under his or her care through guidance, advice, protection, and supervision. It is not appropriate to impose a general duty of supervision on the non-custodial parent over the minor child, because of the non-custodial parent’s obligation to pay child support, the visitation right, parental rights, and other equitable considerations, Unlike custodians, non-custodial parents who do not have direct influence over their children’s behavior under their protection are not generally recognized to have supervisory duties and liability for damages caused by the tors of minors. However, exceptions may be recognized in cases where non-custodial parents have a position and circumstances similar to custodians and where there is foreseeable and controllable supervision of the minor’s torts. The Decision is significant as the Supreme Court’s first statement on whether non-custodial parents have a supervisory duty regarding the torts of minor children, indicating that under special circumstances, such duties may be recognized even for non-custodial parent, and it is also significant in that it recognizes that there are exceptional cases in which a non-custodial parent may be recognized as having a duty of supervision over a minor child and may be liable for tort damages for breach of such a duty, and provides specific examples of two types of such cases.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
A 2024 study studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: