Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Language is viewed as a combinatorial symbol system, and speech as a specialization within multimodal symbolic communication. This paper assumes that a growing ability to suppress reflexive responses to stimuli (Striedter 2005) intensified anticipatory, hypothesis-testing activity, and that the (inner) try-out of vocalizations facilitated the exploitation of the potential of the symbol. Vocal utterances that turned out to be successful (e.g. in a put-the-baby-down scenario; Falk 2004), had the chance to become part of cumulative cultural transmission.The concept of the symbol in Peirce (1904, 1906) admits (i) a description of iconic visual gestures and of onomatopoetic vocalizations as “iconic symbols”, (ii) viewing the symbol as a representation of concepts, and (iii) viewing meaningful units in non-human communication, like monkey alarm-calls, as symbols. The symbolic function enables communicating abstract matters. And it enables “translatability”, for instance between vocal and visual-gestural components of utterances. Thus, we do not need the assumption (cf. Givon 2002) of an evolutionary transition from a rather iconic, visual-gestural to a “more symbolic” communication. Our approach to speech evolution amounts to a relatively parsimonious reconstruction that avoids the assumption of a qualitative difference in the cognitive systems of human and non-human animals (cf. Hauser et al. 2002) and the untestable implication that no other animal has the respective trait. The focus of the reconstruction is on specializations of working-memory capacities that amplify the auditory-vocal feed-back system, and particularly on specializations of extremely powerful statistical learning mechanisms (Saffran et al. 1996a,b; Saffran 2001). Advanced statistical learning and advanced “analogical abilities” (Gentner 2010) may explain the development of language early in childhood and early in the hominin evolution. We further discuss language universals that obviously reflect constraints of relevant information processing.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
August Fenk (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: