Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Abstract Using blood-based extracellular RNA (circulating cell-free RNA; exRNA) as a clinical biomarker requires validated procedures for sample collection and processing and RNA quantification. No study to date has systematically tested pre-analytical variables affecting transcriptome-wide exRNA analysis. We evaluated and compared ten blood collection tubes, three time intervals between blood draw and blood processing, and eight RNA purification methods using the supplier-specified minimal and maximal biofluid input volumes. The impact on deep transcriptome profiling of both microRNAs and messenger RNAs in blood plasma or serum was separately assessed for each pre-analytical variable and for interactions among a selected pre-analytical variable set, resulting in 456 complete extracellular transcriptomes. The processing and analysis workflow was controlled using 189 synthetic spike-in RNA molecules. In blood collection tube comparisons, manufacturer-designated preservation tubes did not stabilize exRNA well, causing variations in RNA concentration and number of detected genes over time, together with increased replicate variability. We also document large performance differences in RNA purification methods, affecting detected gene number, replicate variability and observed transcriptome complexity, and demonstrate technical interactions between certain blood collection tubes, purification methods and time intervals. Our results are comprehensively summarized in 11 analytical performance metrics that enable an informed selection of the best sample processing workflow for a given experiment. We provide robust quality control metrics for exRNA quantification methods with validated standard operating procedures (SOPs), and put forward recommendations for both users and manufacturers of RNA purification methods and blood collection tubes, collectively, essential groundwork for future exRNA-based precision medicine applications.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Vandesompele et al. (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: