Longitudinal Changes in a Claims-Based Frailty Proxy Measure Compared to Concurrent Changes in the Fried Frailty Phenotype

Background Frailty is a dynamic aging-related syndrome, but measuring frailty transitions is challenging. The Faurot frailty index is a validated Medicare claims-based frailty proxy based on demographic and billing information. We evaluated whether 3-year changes in the Faurot frailty index were consistent with concurrent changes in the frailty phenotype in a cohort of older adults. Methods We used longitudinal data from the National Health and Aging Trends Study (NHATS) with Medicare claims linkage (2010–2018). We identified older adults (66+ years) in the 2011 and 2015 NHATS cohorts with at least 1 year of Medicare fee-for-service continuous enrollment (N = 6 951). We described annual changes in mean claims-based frailty for up to 3 years, based on concurrent transitions in the frailty phenotype. Results At baseline, 32% were robust, 48% prefrail, and 19% frail based on the frailty phenotype. Mean claims-based frailty for older adults who were robust at baseline and worsened to frail increased over 3 years (0.09–0.25). Similarly, those who worsened from prefrail to frail experienced an increase in mean claims-based frailty (0.14–0.26). Improvements in the frailty phenotype did not correspond to decreases in claims-based frailty. Older adults whose frailty phenotype improved over time had a lower baseline claims-based frailty score than those who experienced stable or worsening frailty. Conclusions Older adults who experienced a frailty phenotype worsening over 3 years experienced concurrent increases in the Faurot frailty index. Our results suggest that claims data may be used to identify clinically meaningful worsening in frailty.