Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Regarding taxes, no taxation without law and tax equalitarianism in the constitutional law are the most important principles in the legislation and enforcement of tax laws. For example, in the case of tax avoidance, if no taxation without law is emphasized, there is a limit that it cannot be taxed, and some believe that if tax equalitarianism is emphasized, taxation is possible. However, in conclusion, these problems must be resolved through legislative legislation, and it will not be allowed to go beyond the scope of interpretation of relevant regulations by law enforcement or legal interpretation of the administration or the judiciary. In this respect, the relationship between no taxation without law and tax equalitarianism is understood that tax equalitarianism constitutes the actual content of no taxation without law. On the other hand, among Japanese case, it is not a tax avoidance issue, but it has been a problem for certain taxpayers based on a high tax rate, while other taxpayers have been taxed based on a low tax rate. In this case, given that the application of a high rate is particularly reasonable, the issue of legal disposition under the law and the imposition of a low rate of tax contrary to the law was reviewed. In this regard, first, there is an opinion that tax equalitarianism takes precedence over no taxation without law. Considering tax equality, tax equalitarianism takes precedence over no taxation without law in this case, given that there are many taxes according to low rates rather than high rates. This is thought to have been the result of relieving taxpayers who are taxed according to the high rate, in that they cannot request equality of illegality. Second, it is a view that the principle of legitimacy starts from tax equalitarianism, not no taxation without law. In this way, it is believed that the above issue can be resolved smoothly. However, more diverse reviews of the history and other research are needed for this. Third, as a practical content of no taxation without law, tax equalitarianism works in enforcement and legislation, and in the relevant legislation, it should be legislated in consideration of equality with enforcement in mind. If the relevant legal provisions had been more clearly defined, the taxation disposition would not have changed as in the above case, which is an inherent constraint of No taxation without law, and high-rate taxpayers should be taxed the same as other taxpayers. From the above discussion, it can be seen that there may be various views on the relationship between No taxation without law and Tax equalitarianism. In particular, it will be necessary to look at the two as important examples for us in the future as they are commonly discussed in the tax laws of Korea and Japan. In discussing vertical and horizontal equality in tax egalitarianism, which constitutes the content of tax legalism, it is possible to examine in-depth the discipline density and clarity of legal provisions as well as how the principle of legality harmonizes with No taxation without law in legal content equality.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
A 2024 study studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: