Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Recently, a decision was sentenced on the particularly reliable state of Article 314 of the Criminal Procedure Act regarding the evidence admissibility of a will, and the content of the decision was almost the same as the previous decision. ‘The statement or preparation was made in particularly reliable state’ of Article 314 of the Criminal Procedure Act means that there is little room for falsity to intervene in the content of the statement or preparation of the document, and there are specific and external circumstances that guarantee the reliability or voluntary of the statement or contents of document. Since a particularly reliable state is one of the requirements for the recognition of the admissibility of evidence, it is reasonable to determine it according to formal standards of law as much as possible. Therefore, the judgment of a particularly reliable state must be strictly distinguished from the judgment of credibility or probative power, and the content of the evidence should not be reviewed beyond the minimum related to the external circumstances. Nevertheless, the decision determined the particularly reliable state of the will by considering the reliability of not only the will itself but also other evidence. In fact, the decision has overturned the judgment of the original court about fact-finding by evaluating the credibility and probative power of all the evidence, including the will. In this case, considering that the deceased, who was about to die, wrote a will stating that he was an accomplice with the defendants, and that the deceased had no motive to accuse the defendants false, it was appropriate to admit the particularly reliable state of the will. There is a great need to judge the particularly reliable state specifically and individually due to the nature of the conceptual element. In the future, court practice should move away from juddging credibility and move toward providing guidelines that can be actually applied by lower courts, that is, categorizing situations that indicate the particularly reliable state in detail.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
A 2024 study studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: