Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Since the fall of the Berlin Wall, earnest grappling with how to learn from the horrors of twentieth-century history has grown into a vigorous German export industry.Esra Özyürek's excellent book, which explores the positioning of Germans from Muslim cultural backgrounds in the nation's discourses and practices of Holocaust memory, casts a salutary critical light on some of the underlying assumptions of this regime of civic pedagogy.Rooted both in subtle and sophisticated anthropological fieldwork and in sharp historical and theoretical analysis, Özyürek's study offers a deeply illuminating window into the worldview and lived experience of the young male Turkish and Arab Germans who are drawn into this memory work.It also provides an incisive dissection of the elisions, confusions and evasions of these culturally targeted programmes.Subcontractors of Guilt should be required reading for anybody seeking to understand the fundamental role of historical memory in the deep-seated problematics of ethnic and religious inclusion in contemporary Germany.The focus in Germany on Muslim antisemitism is not, Özyürek reminds us, justified by the evidence.The definition both of antisemitism and of the category of Muslim or Muslim-background Germans are far from straightforward, but the latest federal government report on antisemitism in the country noted that there was no clear demonstration that this prejudice was more prevalent in that broad group than in the population as a whole.Hate crimes, meanwhile -whether against Jews or against Muslims or other immigrant-background communities -are overwhelmingly committed by right-wing white Germans (72-3).These facts have not, though, dislodged the dominance in German thinking of what Özyürek calls the "export-import theory" of Muslim antisemitism.On this account, Germany remains the originary source of antisemitism, and guilty of having exported it far and wide during the Nazi period, including to the Middle East.Through their intensive engagement with their past, though, postwar Germans have essentially overcome their antisemitism.This hard and virtuous work now risks being unravelled through the "re-import" of antisemitism by Muslims: both recent immigrants from the Middle East and more long-standing German residents, most numerously from Turkey, supposedly influenced by the culture of their homeland.The battle against Muslim antisemitism in Germany, according to this theory, readily appears as the new frontline against antisemitism in toto.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Adam Sutcliffe (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: