Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
millennials, fear of climate change is a factor in their decision not to have children. 3 Meanwhile, a 2023 systematic review of such studies by a team of researchers at UCL found that in 12 out of 13 studies, conducted worldwide, stronger concerns about climate change were associated with a desire to have fewer children, or none at all (Dillarstone et al 2023).Recent books by authors such as Gina Rushton (2023), Elizabeth Rush (2023) and Anastasia Berg and Rachel Wiseman (2024) have discussed climate anxiety at length in the context of the decision whether to have children.Even if our children don't meaningfully contribute to global warming themselves -in a rapidly warming world, are we really able to guarantee that they are able to live a good-enough life?Granted, there are still plenty of people -many of them infinitely more powerful than the ones making the case against human reproduction -who think, and support policies designed to achieve, the exact opposite.Across the developed world, fertility rates have stalled in recent years -taking a further hit as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic (Aasve et al 2021).This has led to a discussion, parallel to the one around climate change, of a coming 'demographic time bomb', with the concern being that rapidly ageing societies, such as the UK, Italy, or Japan, will prove unable to sustain themselves -regardless of whether or not they're also underwater, or on fire.In certain countries, this talk has also been fuelled by fears of geopolitical decline relative to younger, more fecund nations (see e.g.Yglesias 2020) -as well as the racist and/or xenophobic fear that immigrant labour will be required to care for ageing native populations.Reactionary governments have cited these fears in moving to curtail access to abortion and contraception, or put programmes in place that incentivise women to stay at home and have as many babies as possible: see for instance Poland's generous child benefit policy, which has been correlated both with an increase in the fertility rate, and with more women dropping out of the labour market. 4 The political prominence of such views is worth noting.But it's also fair to say that they don't get as much play in academic philosophical debates.In academic environmental ethics, the association of having fewer kids with environmental responsibility dominates.Thus Sarah Conly (2016), Travis Rieder (2016), and Trevor Hedberg (2019) have all argued that the climate crisis gives us a duty to reduce family size.Leonard Kahn (2019), meanwhile, goes even further, arguing that all pregnant people in the developed world have a duty to abort the foetuses they are currently gestating.Other work focuses not on the question of if the climate crisis gives us a duty to reduce family size, but rather on what we ought to do, given that it does.Thus Anca Gheaus (2019) has argued in support of multi-parent families: in order to give everyone who wants it the opportunity to raise children, without then needing to do anything environmentally irresponsible.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Tom Whyman (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: