Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The identity of online commenters is frequently associated with stereotypes such as ‘the angry white male’. However, the predominance of a small unrepresentative group in online commenting sections in response to news articles potentially causes a disproportionate influence on the public debate. In order to estimate how disproportionate the situation is, we uncovered the demographic composition of online commenting sections by conducting a large-scale survey (n=5,490) with a representative sample of the Dutch population – the LISS panel. We combined this data with demographic background variables and previously collected data on political views and values, to provide a detailed description of the identity of online commenters in comparison to non-commenters. Our results show that online commenters are overall somewhat more likely to be male (55%), and the age group of 45-54 years old has the largest share of commenters (18% for men, 13% for women). Furthermore, we found little or no differences for education levels, income, location, political preferences, and cultural background, suggesting that there is no striking overrepresentation of specific groups among online commenters in general. However, when looking at the profiles of online commenters as a function of the topic and platform of discussion, differences start to emerge for gender, age, and education levels. For example, men are more present in discussions about politics (67%), and women are more likely to engage in discussions on social media over internal commenting platforms. Lastly, we found no differences related to age and gender distributions for those with a higher commenting frequency, but a higher frequency does go hand in hand with more support for national populist and radical-right political parties and a decreased trust in politics. Taken together, our findings provide a nuanced picture of who online commenters are, and how representative they are of the general population.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Linden et al. (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: