Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Instant buyers (iBuyers)—companies that buy and sell homes based on automated valuation models (AVMs)—now hold more than 5% market share in some USA cities. In this work, we investigate the fairness of iBuyers by constructing a dataset that links racial demographics from voter records with detailed property information on over 50,000 real estate transactions. Using Bayesian hierarchical modeling we find that: 1. iBuyers Decrease the Racial Sales Price Gap Between Black and White Home Sellers. Controlling for over 50 property features we find that iBuyers reduce the racial price gap that otherwise exists between homes sold by Black and White homeowners. This is not, however, a result of equity achieved through proprietary AVMs, but rather a result of both Black and White homeowners being similarly disadvantaged by iBuyers' low purchase prices; and, 2. iBuyers Increase Property Conversion Rates from Individual to Institutional Ownership. We trace iBuyers' purchases as well as their follow-on sales of homes in Mecklenburg County. In doing so, we show that iBuyers increase the rate at which properties are converted from being individually owned to institutionally owned. The eventual purchasers of iBuyer homes include national and international rental companies that have been tied to high eviction rates and poor property management. As with sale prices, we find that rather than reapportioning this social harm more equitably, iBuyers are simply increasing the rate at which homes bought from White homeowners are converted to institutional ownership. Ultimately, our analysis suggests that iBuyers are Equalizing Housing Outcomes by Extending Real Estate Harms Typically Isolated to Black Homeowners to White homeowners as Well.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Slaughter et al. (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: