Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
There is overwhelming evidence that virtual consultations can reduce health care carbon emissions, largely by reducing travel related to in-person appointments.[1] Due to the incredibly important nature of this topic,[2] it is crucial not only to advance scientific discourse but also to highlight other ways in which telemedicine can be made more sustainable, such as the use of wearables[3] and, above all, smartwatches and artificial intelligence (AI) solutions on mobile phones, especially when they are integrated into a telemonitoring platform, with a clinical advisory service that manages alerts via digital consultation. Drawing from our experience with a patient telemonitoring program for different health conditions,[4] which involved 16,200 patients over three years (2020–2023), 864,209 wearable measurements were obtained. The majority (97%) were from smartwatches (34% from Apple, 23% from Garmin, 20% from Google Fit, 8% from Fitbit, 4% from Samsung, 3% from Strava, 3% from Polar, and 2% from Withings). However, 3% of patients, depending on the profile, also used connected health devices such as electrocardiograms, spirometers, pulse oximeters, scales, and blood pressure devices. The remote monitoring platform allows the measurement and visualization of the evolution of vital signs captured by devices connected to a health application (Figure 1). The intelligent system analyses these measurements and allows the detection of anomalies. The clinical team manages alerts, periodically reviews the information received and proactively contacts patients via digital consultation, prioritizing based on the information received. The mobile application also allows patients to contact the clinical team via digital consultation 24/7 (Figure 2).Figure 1.: Screenshots of the telemonitoring mobile application that integrates facial transdermal optical imaging with AI and wearables connected with a clinical advisory service that manages alerts via digital consultation.Figure 2.: Features of the telemonitoring platform. Patients' utilization of regular smartwatches, which already incorporate health measurement capabilities, eliminates the need to purchase specific devices for disease control. In doing so, smartwatches not only reduce costs for patients but also minimize electronic waste and resource consumption associated with dedicated medical devices. Furthermore, simple measurements of physiological and activity parameters captured by wearables often serve as indicators of disease decompensation, enabling timely interventions and improved patient outcomes.[5,6] By using AI and facial transdermal optical imaging on mobile devices, 382,943 measurements were also obtained. These measurements are integrated into our mobile health application, which uses NuraLogix's cloud-based software to determine measurements based on facial blood flow information. The application allows the measurement of heart rate, respiratory rate, and blood pressure, among other variables.[7] This technology allows blood pressure to be measured with an average overall accuracy of 95% in the following ranges: systolic: 100–139 mmHg; diastolic: 60–89 mmHg. Blood pressure prediction models predict blood pressure with a measurement bias ± standard deviation of 0.39 ± 7.30 mmHg for systolic blood pressure and -0.20 ± 6.00 mmHg for diastolic blood pressure. For heart rate, the application has a good correlation with electrocardiogram measurements, with an average overall accuracy of 95% and with a result within 3 beats of the true value in the heart rate range between 30 bpm and 200 bpm. In compliance with United States Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act and European Union General Data Protection Regulation regulations and to protect privacy, certain personal data collected, such as facial images and video recordings, are not stored. This technology eliminates the need for additional specific devices, reducing the production and utilization of specialized medical equipment. To maintain consistency in the data collected between different devices, all data are stored in the same database, and the origin is classified based on the type of measurement device. This information is available to both the patient and health care personnel at all times, who can differentiate the origin of the measurements (Figure 3).Figure 3.: The back office of the medical team, showing the telemonitoring program with the data from the patient's different devices; the medical team is able to differentiate the source of each data point (whether it comes from a wearable or AI facial analysis). Our telemonitoring program has successfully facilitated 39,098 digital consultations for medical advice and for managing alerts generated by wearable and mobile devices. Communication channels for consultations were predominantly chat (67%), video consultations (24%), and phone calls (9%). We think that it is essential that wearable health data be remotely monitored by a medical team to avoid trips to the hospital to resolve concerns over possible deviations. We calculated the net carbon savings of performing a visit online by summing the carbon savings derived from the avoided patient travel for a face-to-face appointment and subtracting the videoconferencing and phone call emissions. To calculate the net CO2 emission data avoided owing to patients' switch to digital processes, we worked with the Carbon Trust, a global climate change and sustainability consultancy. We reviewed statistical data on the average distances travelled by Sanitas customers to go from their homes to a doctor's surgery; with these data, we calculated the average distance covered nationally (approximately 13 km for a round trip). The methodology included a review of the different modes of travel used by the population, according to national statistics registers of Spain and the UK.[8] Different means of transport were analysed (walking, cycling, bus, train, car) with the following considerations. In large provinces (Madrid, Barcelona and Valencia), 50% of the clients travelled by car, 21% by bus, 26% by train or metro and 3% by a non-polluting method of transport (walking, cycling). In the remaining provinces, 80% of the respondents travelled by car, 9% by bus, 8.0% by train and 3% by a non-polluting method of transport. In its methodology, the Carbon Trust included in its equation the CO2 emissions generated by using digital tools for video appointments (energy consumption of equipment and data transmission) or to download and save a digital medical report. Emissions related to videoconferencing were subtracted from the total avoided emissions to establish a "net" quota of avoided CO2. To calculate the emissions generated during a video consultation, the energy consumption of a videoconference was estimated to last an average of 9.5 minutes and was calculated based on the energy intensity of data centres, data transmission and the use of devices, in line with the reports of the International Energy Agenda. The emission factor of the Spanish electricity mix was used. The calculation above yielded an average of 3.057 kg of net CO2 emissions avoided per digital appointment.[9] Assuming that chat consultations have a similar impact and by multiplying the calculated average savings of 3057 kg of CO2 per appointment by the 39,098 digital consultations that were made through the telemonitoring program, we achieved a net reduction of 119.5 tons of CO2 emissions over the three-year period. Nowhere are the effects of climate change manifesting more clearly than on human health. The modern health care sector contributes to this serious phenomenon and is simultaneously affected by it. Although transportation for health reasons represents only 1.5% of the total number of trips,[9] ameliorating the environmental impacts of the health care sector and reducing greenhouse gas emissions can not only improve health for everyone but also reduce the costs of care.[10] In conclusion, our experience with the integration of wearables and facial transdermal optical imaging with AI on mobile devices into a medical telemonitoring platform holds immense potential for improving patient care while minimizing environmental impact by reducing CO2 emissions through digital management.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Serra et al. (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: