Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Scrapbooking's popularity surged from the middle of the nineteenth century until the commencement of World War I as millions filled albums with their favorite clippings, autographs, and ephemera. The Poe Museum owns an important example compiled during the 1840s and 1850s by Revolutionary War orator Patrick Henry's granddaughter Lucy Dorothea Henry (1822–98). This album's contents, which include the handwriting of Poe, Hawthorne, and Dickens, have been thoroughly cataloged and digitized, but a second, long-forgotten scrapbook in the museum's collection may also be of interest to Poe researchers.Although the item entered the museum's collection in 1929, its contents were not cataloged and photographed until last year. The reason for this oversight is that the scrapbook is housed in a copy of the biographical memoir The Home Life of Poe (1907) by Susan Archer Weiss (1822–1917), so the piece was listed in the museum's accession book as merely one of the institution's four copies of that volume and eventually relegated to an off-site storage location. Of the museum's three other copies of The Home Life of Poe (fig. 1), one was kept in the reference library for the benefit of researchers, while the other two were used for exhibits because they were inscribed by the author and her son, respectively. Neither easily accessible to scholars nor considered worthy of being exhibited, the neglected copy recently came to the curator's attention when it was being photographed for the museum's online collections database.The book originally belonged to Anne Rhea Bachman Hyde (1868–1959). Born in Tennessee, Hyde graduated from the Sayre Institute in Lexington, Kentucky, in 1886. Three years later, she married Charles Robert Hyde, a Presbyterian minister who presided over churches in Charleston, South Carolina; Little Rock, Arkansas; St. Louis, Missouri; and Richmond, Virginia. It was during the Hydes' time in Virginia's capital that fellow Richmond resident Weiss wrote The Home Life of Poe. Hyde must have acquired her copy shortly after publication because most of the clippings date to within a few years of 1907. She carefully glued newspaper and magazine articles, poetry, illustrations, photographs, and manuscript material throughout the chapters, onto the endpapers and flyleaves, and on extra pages she added to the beginning and end of the book. Since Weiss's book does not contain any illustrations, Hyde inserted clipped illustrations on appropriate pages to accompany Weiss's text. In one case, Hyde added her own photograph of the home (fig. 2) of Union spy Elizabeth Van Lew (1818–1900), whom Weiss mentions in the book.While the portraits of Poe and the poetic tributes to him by Father Tabb (1845–1909), John Henry Boner (1845–1903), and others that Hyde added to the album are already well-known, a few of her newspaper clippings (fig. 3) provide interesting details about Poe's personality. These include an article from a 1903 issue of The Outlook containing a firsthand account by Thomas Wentworth Higginson (1823–1911) of Poe's disastrous recitation at the Boston Lyceum in 1845.Another notable clipping is an obituary of Poe's childhood friend and classmate Creed Thomas (1812–99) from the February 24, 1899, issue of an unidentified Richmond newspaper. The article devotes far less space to Thomas's life and career than it does to his accounts of Poe's student days. One of the many amusing anecdotes concerns an amateur theatrical production Poe and his friends performed on a makeshift stage. On the night in question, Poe and a fellow teenaged thespian interrupted a Shakespeare play by fighting over a wig in front of the audience.The oldest piece in the collection is a clipping of a favorable review of Susan Weiss's first volume of poetry from the February 1860 issue of the Nashville Home Circle. One of the newest is a review of the same author's The Home Life of Poe from 1907.Among the manuscript material is a loose scrap of paper containing a hastily written account of a conversation about Weiss with one of her former neighbors Terresa Johnson (born 1893), who recalls that Weiss was "a much invalided person who taught her [Johnson] the deaf and dumb language, told amusing stories—talked of Poe." Because Weiss was hard of hearing, many of Poe's biographers have doubted that she could have engaged in the many in-depth conversations with the poet that she describes in both The Home Life of Poe and the magazine articles she wrote about him, but this note confirms that, even in her later years, Weiss could communicate effectively enough to tell "amusing stories." Despite this clarification, many of the stories Weiss relates in her book are riddled with historical inaccuracies and unreliable sources.Weiss is far from the only one to misstate important details when writing about Poe. Another culprit is Douglas Vass Martin (1855–1924), whose account written directly onto one of the flyleaves (fig. 4) is probably the most interesting piece in Hyde's collection. The piece reads,After this, Hyde added on a later page, "The note on P. 5. Was written for me by Mr. Douglas Martin of St. Charles, Mo." and "Mr. Martin's mother was (if I remember correctly) Eleanor Vass of Richmond and his father was a well known minister."Since Martin's mother, Marietta Susannah Vass Martin (1829–79), was too young to have attended school with Poe's sister, Rosalie Mackenzie Poe (1810–74), it is more likely that he was thinking of his grandmother, Eleanor Hawkins Smith Vass (1806–82). The latter lived in Richmond and was old enough to have attended school at the Mackenzie School for Girls with the poet's sister. The former was young enough to have taken classes taught by Rosalie Poe, who taught art and penmanship at the same school as an adult.Hyde's note adds to the confusion by identifying Martin's grandmother as his mother. Despite the discrepancies over this important detail, the anecdote otherwise bears a similarity to other descriptions of Poe's private readings for Richmond women. The mention of Rosalie Poe being an object of ridicule is found in a similar account by Susan Weiss, who recalled in "The Last Days of Edgar A. Poe" from the March 1878 issue of Scribner's Magazine that Rosalie Poe interrupted one of her brother's private recitations of "The Raven" by sitting on his knee. According to Weiss, this inspired the amused poet to comment that he should bring his sister to all his readings "to act the part of the raven, in which she seemed born to excel."The event Martin describes most likely took place between July 14 and September 26, 1849, when Poe is known to have been in Richmond. During that period, he delivered private readings in the homes of Susan Weiss, Elizabeth Van Lew, and Jane Mackenzie (1783–1865) in addition to two public lectures at the Exchange Hotel. Rosalie Poe accompanied him to these engagements and followed him on visits to his friends Catherine Poitiaux (dates unknown) and John Strobia (1785–1856) and to his fiancée Elmira Shelton (1810–88). For this reason, it is entirely plausible that she could have attended the private reading described by Martin—even if we cannot be sure if it was his mother or grandmother who witnessed the event.Since rediscovering Hyde's scrapbook, the museum's curatorial staff has listed and photographed its contents (fig. 5) for the Poe Museum's online collections database at poemuseum.org. As with any scrapbook, this one reveals as much about its compiler as it does about Poe. It shows that Anne Hyde was a meticulous and organized archivist with a special interest in Poe. In fact, she devoted her life to historical research. Hyde served as the state secretary, state historian, and chaplain of the Tennessee Daughters of the American Revolution and as the historian-general of the United Daughters of the Confederacy. Her publications include several articles on historical topics in addition to the book An Historical Account of the United Daughters of the Confederacy (1911). Although she bequeathed most of her personal library to the University of Tennessee at Chattanooga, we are fortunate that she decided to contribute her copy of The Home Life of Poe to a much worthier institution. Now the articles she carefully adhered to its pages over a century ago are available online for the benefit of Poe researchers.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Christopher P. Semtner (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: