Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The following article was chosen as the 2023 Translational Journal of the American College of Sports Medicine Paper of the Year: Kasper KB, Nye NS, Casey TM, Cockerell MG, Trigg SD. The effect of lightweight shoes on air force basic training injuries: a randomized controlled trial. Transl J Am Coll Sports Med. 2023;8(4):1. doi:10.1249/TJX.0000000000000234 Musculoskeletal injuries (MSKI) are common among military recruits engaged in initial entry training (1). This finding can be attributed, in part, to the running and marching required during training. There have been many attempts to mitigate MSKI in the military through the use of prescribed footwear and orthotics (2,3). In order to "provide sufficient choices to minimize the incidence of athletic injuries in initial entry training," the 2017 National Defense Authorization Act reinterpreted the 1947 Berry Amendment, a law used to promote domestic commerce through the obligated purchase of American-made products by the military, to include athletic footwear issued to military recruits (3,4). Although the employment of Berry-compliant contracted footwear may have promoted uniformity and equity among military recruits, end users have expressed criticism and dissatisfaction pertaining to the fit and function of these footwear, despite no evidence of footwear choice on injury risk (3). In a parallel randomized controlled trial, Kasper and colleagues (5) compared the effects of a commercially available athletic shoe that was lighter weight, had a lower heel-to-toe drop, and had a wider toe box with the standard-issue, Berry-compliant athletic footwear on MSKI prevalence, training delays, and perceived comfort in US Air Force recruits. In the experimental group, a sample of 393 recruits (307 males, 86 females) were randomly assigned to receive the lightweight footwear (Topo Athletic Fli-Lyte 4). In the control group, a sample of 366 recruits (274 males, 92 females) were randomly selected within the same squadron to receive the standard issue, Berry-compliant footwear. Both groups were followed through a 5-wk training course. The primary study outcomes included frequency of injury, delayed graduation, fitness assessment pass success, and perceived satisfaction and feedback pertaining to the footwear. Kasper and colleagues (5) found no significant differences in fitness assessment pass success between groups or time-based effects within groups. Although there were no significant between-group differences in MSKI prevalence or frequency of delayed graduation in combined-sex groups, there were significant and large-magnitude risk reductions observed for bone stress injuries in male recruits in the experimental group only, once sex was factored (absolute risk reduction: 6.05%, relative risk reduction: 43.62%, numbers needed to treat: 16.5). There were no significant group differences observed among female recruits. Pertaining to perceived comfort, the frequency of respondents affirming discomfort was 7% lower in the experimental group compared to controls (experimental: 19.9% vs control: 26.9%). The significant findings in this study are important because they identify a potential mitigating strategy for one of the most common injuries incurred during initial military training. The nonsignificant findings in this study are equally important and are consistent with those previously reported in US Coast Guard recruits and across service branches (2,3). Etiological factors for MSKI in military members are complex and multifaceted (6). As such, prophylactic interventions should be multimodal and individualized to the specific needs of the recruit and tailored to the demands of the training environment. Because changes in athletic footwear may be an important consideration, modifications to Berry-compliant contracted footwear based on evidence and feedback from end-users are certainly warranted.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
John J. Fraser (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: