Recurrence and Survival after Robotic vs. Laparoscopic Liver Resection in Very-Early to Early Stage (BCLC 0-A) Hepatocellular Carcinoma: A Retrospective Cohort Study with Propensity Score Matching

Abstract Background Robotic (RLR) and laparoscopic liver resection (LLR) provide similar short-term outcomes in hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) of stage BCLC 0-A, but data on recurrence and survival are still lacking in populations with high prevalence of cirrhosis. Aims We investigated the outcomes of RLR vs. LLR for HCC in a cohort with high rate of cirrhosis. The primary endpoint was recurrence-free (RFS) and overall survival (OS); incidence, pattern, and treatment of recurrence were the secondary ones. Methods RLRs and LLRs for HCC of stage BCLC 0-A from two tertiary centers for liver surgery were retrospectively reviewed. Propensity score matching (PSM) was used to mitigate selection bias. Survival was estimated with Kaplan Meier method with Log rank. Results One-hundred-ninety-six patients underwent RLR (n=68) or LLR (n=128) for BCLC 0-A HCC. After 1:1 PSM, two groups (RLR=68; LLR=68) of patients with similar characteristics, liver function and HCC features were obtained: age (median) 71-year-old, males 73.5%, underlying cirrhosis 91.2% (Child A 96.8%, MELD 9 96%), portal hypertension 22.1%, single-HCC 90.4%. At a median follow-up of 29.0 months, 2- and 5-year RFS were 78.0 vs. 59.0% and 54.0 vs. 53.0% (p=0.107), while OS was 97.0 vs. 90.0% and 87.0 vs. 90.0% (p=0.951) for RLR vs. LLR respectively. Incidence of recurrence was similar (35.3 vs. 39.7%; p=0.723) and was mostly within the liver (29.4 vs. 30.9%; p=1.000) or within 2 years after hepatectomy (54.2 vs. 81.5%, p=0.116) in RLR vs. LLRs. Curative-intent treatment of recurrences did not differ (liver transplantation 19.6%, redo-resection 15.7%) except for a tendency to more redo-resections of recurrences after RLR (29.2 vs. 3.7%; p=0.062). Conclusion Oncologic outcomes of RLR were not inferior to those of LLR in selected HCC patients of stage BCLC 0-A with underlying cirrhosis. Both techniques guaranteed similar salvageability at HCC recurrence in our experience.