Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Reviewed by: The Atrocity of Hunger: Starvation in the Warsaw, Łódź, and Kraków Ghettos during World War II by Helene J. Sinnreich Katrin Paehler The Atrocity of Hunger: Starvation in the Warsaw, Łódź, and Kraków Ghettos during World War II. By Helene J. Sinnreich. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2023. Pp. 300. Cloth $99.99. ISBN 9781009100083. Helene J. Sinnreich's book, The Atrocity of Hunger: Starvation in the Warsaw, Łódź, and Kraków Ghettos during World War II, is an absorbing, horrifying, and—by thinking broadly about what she terms "the atrocity of hunger"—smartly conceived study worth careful attention, not only for students of the Holocaust but also for those working on famines and mass violence in general. Its ten comparatively brief chapters, organized by topic but following a rough chronology, might also work in the classroom. Having just assigned several chapters to my students, I will know more about that soon. Sinnreich's book is part of a relatively recent historiographical trend, spearheaded mostly by women historians such as Svenja Bethke, Barbara Engelking, Anna Hájková, Katarzyna Person, and Joanna Sliwa, to name but a few, that centers on the agency and experiences of the Jews in the ghettos and camps. Jewish men, women, and children are this book's main historical actors as well, and their Alltagsgeschichte is the author's tight focus. The irony is, of course, that this trend calls back to the earliest writings about the Holocaust. Survivor scholars, relying on available communal documents and fellow survivors, wrote in this vein, until the shift toward perpetrator history in English- and German-language scholarship all but cut off this approach as a scholarly endeavor. This perpetrator-focused historiography also called into question the scholarly reliability and, indeed, the centrality of primary sources that originated with victims and survivors, and it has taken too many years for scholarship based on these sources to re-emerge in the celebrated mainstream. But Sinnreich shows once more that brilliant history can be written based on these sources, especially by a historian as careful and nuanced as she. See, for example, the multilayered analysis of hunger, starvation, gender roles, gendered expectations, socioeconomics, religious traditions, [End Page 357] and "the corpse of a young girl left naked on a sidewalk" (117–20). Here, Sinnreich steadily lays out the assumptions that undergird the wartime report on the teenager's family and offers a more nuanced, better contextualized, and compassionate reading of their situation. It is one of the book's many analytical masterclasses. Sinnreich's attention to nuance and context makes this book such an important addition to our knowledge about the Holocaust, about hunger and starvation, and about life and death in the ghettos. She is keenly aware of the variety of factors that made access to food possible on all levels, from the individual to the household to the community. A person's or family's prewar status, from social standing to available resources to social networks to gender and religious tradition, mattered. On the communal level, the locus of a ghetto in the German administrative contexts, as well as its prewar economic position and access to local resources, all impacted the ability of a ghetto's internal Jewish administrative apparatus to procure and distribute food. Sinnreich's decision to study three different ghettos drives this point home, and her inclusion of Kraków, less discussed in English literature, is another point of praise. Most importantly, Sinnreich studies the "atrocity of hunger" that engulfed these societies in extremis. Hunger, she emphasizes, is not simply a lack of food or an "embodied experience of starvation" (4) but a state of being that "subsumed all aspect of existence and transformed ghetto life and society" (2), led to a social breakdown, and overturned prewar norms. She focuses her attention on this breakdown in all its facets and cascading effects that eventually reached everyone, and on "coping mechanism and survival strategies" the victims employed with limited effect—both individually but also on a familial and communal level. Sinnreich's nuanced discussion of hunger and access to food ultimately also approaches the elusive question of who had a chance at survival, clearly...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Katrin Paehler (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: