Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Capitulations have long been a subject in Ottoman economic and political historiography. But it is still appropriate to say that there is more to be studied. After Viorel Panaite's remarkable studies, for which he shared the results for several decades, were circulated in the English literature, the publication of new research by both him and his students led to the emergence of systematic knowledge and new approaches, especially in the context of ahitname texts. It is an exciting development to see that Radu Dipratu, who has published an important series of articles about the non-Muslims in the Ottoman lands in the seventeenth century, presents the subjects that form the focus of his studies to the reader in book form. Working at the Institute for South-East European Studies of the Romanian Academy in Bucharest, the author specializes in diplomatic relations between the Ottoman Empire and Protestant and Orthodox European countries, especially Catholic Europe. But one of the author's most distinctive features is that he developed this expertise not only in international relations or diplomatic contexts but also within the internal social and political structure of the Ottoman Empire. Because the author's interest so far has not been limited to only one part of the empire, it has allowed readers to get the idea of regional comparisons. In this sense, his concerns regarding the presence of foreigners in the Ottoman Balkans, Aegean Islands, and the Levant in the seventeenth century and their religious activities in these areas are highly productive.The first part focuses on the ahitnames granted by the Ottoman Empire to the European states where Catholic, Protestant, and Orthodox citizens live. But the main focus of the author's interest is on the ahitnames granted to the Catholics. The first four chapters cover the ahitnames that regulated religious affairs and were granted to the French Empire, Venice, the Habsburg Empire, and the Kingdom of Poland from the beginning of the seventeenth century to the middle of the eighteenth century. The fifth chapter focuses on the seventeenth-century ahitnames granted to the Netherlands and Russia. Most of the capitulations in this first part were elements of bilateral agreements signed following hostile relations between the states; the others were made during a peace period. The second part corresponds to roughly one-third of the book. Here, in three chapters, readers can find details about how Ottoman capitulations regulated Christian pilgrims, clergy, and churches.Dipratu's book makes a substantial contribution to the literature, which contains the weight of the international political and commercial relations of the Europeans in the Ottoman Empire, with more emphasis on the religious activities of foreigners. On the other hand, it makes a difference because it covers not only the city of Jerusalem and its surroundings but also other regions of the empire. The author also pays attention to the fact that a significant number of Catholics, who were citizens of many European states, were subjects of the Ottoman ahitnames. Again, he gives particular importance to diversity in nationality and the religious commonality of the historical actors he discusses.The paragraphs on church repairs (pp. 184–191) contain tangible clues about the author's handling of the subjects. This issue, which has attracted the attention of pre-Ottoman Islamic jurists, clearly shows the concerns of the canonical tradition about Muslim and non-Muslim relations. On the one hand, the increase in the number of non-Muslim places of worship and the expansion of the physical structure, that is, the development of churches, to put it bluntly, was a process that legal scholars carefully tried to prevent. The equivalent of their religious concern in the Ottoman bureaucracy was a political concern. However, one aspect of the freedom of religion and conscience of non-Muslims under Islamic rule was freedom of worship. Thus, the phenomenon of church repair was in the middle of these two tension points and may shift toward one side of the tension line depending on the sociopolitical context. Dipratu's arguments point to significant examples of the appearance of this tension that occurred in different parts of the seventeenth-century Ottoman Empire, particularly the Levant. For instance, whether it is possible to understand the full content of the right of non-Muslims to repair a church, beyond simple daily repairs, and to construct a new structure was on the agenda of both religious and political actors in the Ottoman bureaucracy and representatives of European states.The legal status of Catholics in the Ottoman lands was the border between citizenship and foreignness. As the author successfully emphasizes, their freedoms regarding religious activities contained a series of religious aspects in the context of Muslim-Christian relations and Orthodox-Catholic-Protestant relations, as well as political meanings in the context of Ottoman-European states.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Osman Safa Bursalı (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: