Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The article is devoted to the specifics of the appointment and conduct o f a forensic psychiatric examination. It has been established that sanity, as well as a person's age, are prerequisites for criminal responsibility, which is preceded by one's own conscious volitional choice, which also includes understanding the social significance o f criminal actions or inaction and predicting their consequences. Sanity, along with guilt and responsibility, is the central methodological category of criminal law from the point o f view o f its fundamental importance for the obser\>ance o f human rights and freedoms. That is why it is really important for the investigator, prosecutor and judge to understand the concepts o f sanity, lack o f sanity and limited sanity in order to accurately resolve the issue o f finding a person guilty. It is noted that the legislation of Ukraine does not establish the concept o f a person's mental state, nor does it contain even an approximate list o f criteria that are necessary to assess their significance. And therefore, in the absence o f a single definition o f the concept o f mental state and its criteria, the investigator and prosecutor decides on the issue o f the sanity / lack o f sanity o f a person, as well as the further procedure for carrying out criminal proceedings, based on the conclusion o f a psychiatric examination, which is appointed after establishing the fact o f the commission o f a criminal offense by this or that person. It was concluded that taking into account the norms o f criminal and criminal procedural legislation, court practice in relevant proceedings and analysis o f legal literature, it is possible to distinguish the following categories o f factual grounds and circumstances that indicate the expediency o f conducting a forensic psychiatric examination, namely: 1) information, which indicate that the person was previously or is currently under the supervision o f a psychiatrist; the person was hospitalized and treated in a psychiatric hospital, was recognized as unfit for militant service due to a mental illness: the person was previously found to be insane or was being treated in a relevant institution: 2) information that testifies to certain features o f a person's behavior and may indicate the presence o f a mental illness or disorder o f mental activity; 3j information obtained from the requests submitted by the participants in the proceedings, about the need for a forensic psychiatric examination: 4) information that proves the motiveless nature o f the offense committed or its commission with particidar brutality, which is not characteristic o f a person with a "healthy" psyche.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
О. В. Кузьменко (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: