Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This study explores some of the impacts of policy changes relating to the composition and use of corpus-informed word lists for testing French, German, and Spanish as foreign languages in secondary schools in England. We review requirements for the lexical content of high-stakes examinations in these languages under current and new policy and describe the methodological steps we have taken together with teachers and members of an awarding organisation to create new, corpus-informed vocabulary lists for adolescent, beginner-to-low-intermediate learners. Taking the current, non-obligatory and topic-driven lists as a point of comparison, we test the potential of the new lists to provide lexical coverage of material relevant to adolescents: exam papers, young adult literature, and web language. Despite being 36%–44% (foundation tier) and 11%–21% (higher tier) shorter than the current lists, the new, corpus-informed lists covered an average 11% (foundation) and 18% (higher) more of every genre. It seems likely that these stark results can be attributed to a combination of (i) the nature of content (rather than function) words on the lists, (ii) the negligible coverage benefits by the many multiword phrases on the current lists, and (iii) a more even part-of-speech distribution in the new lists. Our approaches to list creation and evaluation are replicable and can be adapted for use in other beginner-to-low-intermediate contexts.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Finlayson et al. (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: