Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
(3016) Opuntia aulacothele F.A.C. Weber in Bull. Mus. Hist. Nat. (Paris) 10: 392. 1904 [Angiosp.: Cact.], nom. utique rej. prop. Neotypus (vide Kiesling & al. in Bradleya 41: 101. 2023): Argentina: Salta, Dpto. Cafayate, Quebrada de Guachipas, Punilla, 23 Jan 1942, Castellanos (BA No. 46875). The name Opuntia aulacothele was recently discussed in detail by Kiesling & al. (in Bradleya 41: 95–104. 2023) as an earlier and preferred name for O. weberi Speg. (in Anales Mus. Nac. Buenos Aires, ser. 3, 4: 509. 1905), and a brief summary of its application is sufficient here: The name is generally attributed to F.A.C. Weber in accordance with Art. 46.2 (Turland & al. in Regnum Veg. 159. 2018) and was published posthumously by Roland-Gosselin, based on material without a statement of exact provenance, but which Weber had received from Buenos Aires. In a note preserved at the Muséum National d'Histoire Naturelle Paris, Weber reported the origin as the Andes west of San Rafael, and this was also stated in the protologue. Opuntia aulacothele was subsequently treated as perhaps a synonym ("likely of this alliance") of O. corrugata by Britton & Rose (Cactaceae 1: 95. 1919) and, in Airampoa, by Doweld (in Turczaninowia 5(2): 29. 2002), while Backeberg (Cactaceae 1: 425, 443–445. 1959) regarded the name as unidentifiable. Otherwise, the name was never mentioned nor used until Hunt (CITES Cactaceae Checklist: 102. 1992; ed. 2: 245. 1999) and Anderson (Cactus Family: 656. 2001, sub Tephrocactus) listed the name with a question mark as referring to O. weberi. Crook & Mottram (in Bradleya 13: 107. 1995) listed the previously proposed suggestions for synonymizations and noted the issue of priority. Iliff (in Succ. Pl. Res. 6: 178. 2002) also suggested that the name was likely an older synonym of O. weberi, but without making a decision, while Hunt & al. (New Cactus Lex.: 360. 2006) simply referred it to the synonymy of Tephrocactus weberi without further discussion. Eggli (in Anderson & Eggli, Grosse Kakteen-Lex.: 619. 2005) accepted this synonymization but specifically remarked that a proposal to conserve T. weberi was needed to preserve existing usage and maintain nomenclatural stability. On the base of the diligent study by Kiesling & al. (l.c.) of the descriptive details and the information on geographical distribution associated with the names in question, there can be little doubt that they refer to the same species. Kiesling & al. (l.c.) accordingly neotypified the name Opuntia aulacothele as given above, and treated O. weberi (as Tephrocactus weberi) as a synonym. These authors (l.c.) discussed at some length their decision to strictly adhere to the priority rule of Art. 11.4, rather than propose the name for rejection under Art. 14.1. They argued that O. weberi was not of economic value and that its name is not commonly used except in "strictly botanical context" and declared to follow the Code's spirit and its Principle III. This, however, is at variance with Preamble 1 of the Code (provision of a stable method of naming) and its Art. 14.2 (stability of nomenclature). The idea that only names of economically important plant species can be proposed for conservation is outdated, and this provision was eliminated from the Code after the 1988 edition (Greuter & al. in Regnum Veg. 118. 1988), where it still existed, and is not a consideration in any edition of the Code since the Tokyo Code of 1994 (Greuter & al. in Regnum Veg. 131. 1994). Since the name Opuntia aulacothele has never been used as the accepted name of a species in any genus prior to Kiesling & al. (l.c.), who provided the new combination in the genus Tephrocactus, we think that nomenclatural stability is much better served by rejecting it, thus allowing O. (T.) weberi to be retained. Indeed, Art. 56.1 explicitly treats rejection of names as a mechanism to avoid a disadvantageous nomenclatural change. Opuntia (T.) weberi is universally used throughout botanical, floristic and hobby literature, and placing importance simply on priority neglects completely the need for stability.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Eggli et al. (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: