Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Water scarcity and conflict is increasing in many parts of the world due to combined pressures of population growth, climate change, and economic development. Demand management policies, such as water use quotas, markets, or pricing, are critical instruments for managing conflicting needs for scarce freshwater resources. However, implementation of effective water demand management policies is often constrained by high levels of unregulated or ‘illegal’ water abstraction that occurs outside of official monitoring systems and inventories. Understanding the magnitude and drivers of ‘illegal’ water use is essential to design interventions to disentivize or deter unregulated abstraction as part of efforts to support efficient and equitable allocation of limited freshwater resources. However, the unobserved nature of ‘illegal’ water abstractions means information about the drivers and incentives underlying unregulated abstractions remain poorly understood, limiting ability to design effective policy and compliance responses. It should be noted that theft is a nonlinear response that abruptly deviates from conventional behavior (compliance), meaning models calibrated with historical data may not be capable of explaining and address this response. To address this knowledge gap, we develop a new database of historical water theft events leveraging rich case study evidence derived from global, regional, and national news media sources. We apply a combination of manual and automated text analysis methods to demonstrate how news media can be leveraged to provide novel insights about the spatio-temporal distribution, magnitude, drivers, and regulatory responses to illegal water use and abstraction. Our analysis shows that illegal water use is a diverse phenomenon, occurring across multiple water scarcity hotspots and sectors globally. Theft of water is framed as abstraction without an official right or permit, but our analysis also identifies water pollution as another key mechanism through which water may be ‘stolen’ from a system and other users via reduced quality of water-which may be rendered unusable or even damage existing users (e.g., environment). Reported drivers for water theft are diverse, ranging from deliberate illegal abstraction for financial gain or as a response to financial risks during droughts, to poor understanding of complex water rights rules, often aggravated by complex institutional or group dynamics (e.g., groupthink). In low- and middle-income countries, we also find evidence that illegal abstraction is a response to deficiencies in the functioning of official supply systems or permitting arrangements. Critically, our analysis finds only limited evidence of punishment or prosecution of offenders that were found to have abstracted water illegally, indicating that regulatory responses to these events are often limited and may play a role in encouraging non-compliance by water users.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Foster et al. (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: