Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Moving Money: Syrian Refugees Surviving Displacement in Jordan Sarah A. Tobin (bio) Hawala, the unregulated system for the informal transfer of money via passcodes, plays a vital role for Syrian refugees trying to survive in Jordan. The system was regularly utilized in Syria prior to the ongoing and brutal civil war that has created over 5 million refugees. Syrian refugees now have an increased dependency on hawala due to the dissolution of financial institutions within Syria and financial exclusion in countries of exile, including Jordan. The growth of and dependency on hawala by Syrian refugees in Jordan is occurring within a context where formal and digital transfers are both surveilled and access is curtailed. The unregulated system of hawala – and its users – have become targeted for governmental crackdowns on criminal activities such as money laundering, terrorism funding, and counter-terrorism surveillance. This article explores the context of policies and practice of humanitarian aid organizations that utilize cashless and low-cash transfers, as well as of states and agencies of refugee governance that aim to surveil and criminalize unregulated and informal transfers for fear of terrorism. Based on interviews with Syrian refugees and observations inside money exchange businesses in Syrian refugee camps and urban areas in Jordan, I argue that the unstable political situation and conditions of displacement create the need to transfer money and remittances via hawala. Further, that hawala is utilized, despite the political concerns to control such transfers, through adaptation in formality and flexibility in time and space, [End Page 36] creating an institutional spectrum from formal and regulated, to semi-formal and regulated in part, and informal, which is unregulated. In addition, the gendered contours of hawala used by Syrian refugees in Jordan reveal important insights into the ways by which the method simultaneously evades surveillance and grows in use, which helps illuminate the ways that the system fulfils a necessary need for low-cash and cashless transfers by Syrian refugees. Introduction Fatima's cell phone chimes, and she looks at the screen. She is a 37-year-old registered Syrian refugee and single mother in a large city in northern Jordan. A text message has arrived telling her that the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) has deposited her aid for the month and that it is available for withdrawal. She walks a block down the street to an ATM from the Cairo-Amman bank. Fatima stands in front of the ATM, enters the prompts on the keyboard, looks up, and then the built-in machine scans her irises and releases her cash. Fatima does not have a bank account, nor is she legally allowed to have one in Jordan as a refugee. Rather, UNHCR collected her biometric data at registration and uses it monthly to transfer her aid, which she can withdraw at any time. Fatima says, This new official system is great for getting my aid because I'm a registered refugee. But I wish Syrians here had more options to send money to family and friends in Syria, or to receive some help from family in Europe, or to send it to each other in Jordan. This here is just between me and the UN. But what about between me and my family? Or my friends? For now, we use hawala for that. It's not official; it's completely informal. And it's not legal, you know. We can get in a lot of trouble from the Jordanian government for it because they're afraid of terrorists. But what choice do we have? There are no banks that can help us in Jordan. The money we get from the UN is not enough, and it's even worse for my mom in Syria, so I have to think of her too and send her money when I can. As Fatima's experience indicates, official policies and practices that utilize digital technologies for aiding registered refugees are now the norm in Jordan. Like hundreds of thousands of other Syrian refugees in Jordan and since 2017, monthly cash aid has been delivered based on biometric data (which is collected upon registration with the UNHCR) through local ATMs across the country.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sarah A. Tobin (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: