This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
Background Popular ice-sports amongst adolescents in many countries include ice-hockey, para-ice-hockey, and ringette. Injuries and concussions are concerning in these ice-sports, with high rates of bodychecking (high intensity trunk physical contact; BC) and head contacts (HCs). Comparisons across adolescent sports are required for holistic injury prevention planning and implementation. Objective To compare BC, HC, and suspected injury (SI) incidence rates (IR) between adolescent boys' ice-hockey (BC-prohibited, BC-permitted), para-ice-hockey (BC-permitted), girls' ice-hockey (BC-prohibited), and ringette (BC-prohibited). Design Cross-sectional. Setting Canada. Participants Adolescents participating in one of the four ice-sports during the 144 games (range per sport/level: 8–35 games) that were analyzed. Assessment of Risk Factors Comparing BC, HC, and SI rates across four different ice-sports. Main Outcome Measurements Dartfish video-analysis software was used to analyze games for BCs, HCs, and SI IRs. Poisson regression analysis (adjusted for cluster by game and offset by playing minutes) were used to compare BC, HC, and SI IRs using incidence rate ratios (IRR). Results Compared with non-elite boys' ice-hockey (BC-prohibited), there were significantly higher BC IRs in BC-permitted boys' ice-hockey (IRR-non-elite=5.89, 95%CI:4.07–8.53; IRR-elite=9.15, 95%CI:6.63–12.64), para-ice-hockey (IRR=3.30, 95%CI:2.14–5.07), girls ice-hockey (IRR=2.67, 95%CI:1.82–3.90), and ringette (IRR=5.72, 95%CI:4.03–8.11). HC IRs were also significantly higher for BC-permitted boys' ice-hockey (IRR-non-elite=2.64, 95%CI:1.92–3.62; IRR-elite=3.18, 95%CI:2.41–4.18), para-ice-hockey (IRR=3.28, 95%CI:2.00–5.39), girls' ice-hockey (IRR=2.76, 95%CI:2.05–3.71), and ringette (IRR=4.06, 95%CI:3.02–5.46) compared to non-elite boys' ice-hockey (BC-prohibited). SI IRs were also significantly higher for para-ice-hockey (IRR=3.71, 95%CI:1.35–10.20) and ringette (IRR=5.13, 95%CI:2.24–11.74), compared to non-elite (BC-prohibited) boys' ice-hockey. The proportions of player-to-player HCs penalized ranged from 2–20% across sports. Conclusion The BC IRs are alarming in ice-sports prohibiting BC (ringette and female ice-hockey). The high HC and SI IRs in adolescent ice-sports are also concerning. The proportion of HCs penalized is low across all sports/levels, suggesting a need for further policy-enforcement strategies to reduce BC and HCs aimed to prevent injuries and concussions in adolescent ice-sports.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Heming et al. (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: