Double-Identity: the DataThe Elephantine Yahwists possessed a complex double identity, both components of which were used for practical and administrative purposes1.As far as they were concerned, each member was truly Yhwdy2 and truly 'rmy ("Aramean") -even though they were not entirely interchangeable.The following table lists cases where the same person was tagged as Yhwdy in some documents and 'rmy (or Swnḫn) in others: Multiple IdentitiesTable Date (BCE) Document Scribe Identified as … Detachment Mḥsyh br Ydnyh 471 B2.1: 2-3 Plṭyh br 'Aḥyw 'rmy of Syene Varyazata 464 B2.2: 3-4 Itu br Abh Yhwdy of Elephantine the fortress Varyazata 1 For the most recent monographs devoted to this question see Karel van der Toorn, Becoming Diaspora Jews (New Haven, 2019), and Bob Becking, Identity in Persian Egypt: the fate of the Yehudite community of Elephantine (University Park, 2020). 2 This article uses the Aramaic gentilic Yhwdy or, on a cultic level, the adjectives »Yahwistic« or »Yahwist« rather than »Jewish«, to refer to members of the Elephantine community of believers in the deity Yhw and their customs.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gad Barnea (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: