Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
If Willarena Were an Artist Erica N. Cardwell (bio) A writer remembers her mother who, had she been an artist, would have been Sharon Jones, and asks: Am I an artist? Which may be asking, Are all Black women artists? In the fall of 2012, New York Magazine published a brief profile of the late Sharon Jones where the interviewer used versions of the words "force" and "power" to describe her, an unoriginal observation of her intuition, struggling to convey depth while observing a Black woman. The word "artist" was never mentioned. Sharon possessed an essence, an intuitive part that the interviewer wasn't trying hard enough to identify, a major reason why "artist" holds such significance, specifically when the word isn't used. Years before this profile was published, I witnessed a white woman testifying at a performance of Sharon Jones & the Dap-Kings at Irving Plaza in New York. It was 2006, a Thursday. This woman's fingers were splayed in an arc above us, pursuing the sound, still enough to be alone, warm in the presence of spirit. Her actions said, receive me, while the knowing movement of her hips said that someone already had. I wanted her to dance more; in fact, I wanted her to look at me, as we momentarily believed in the same things. When I am described as an artist, I feel that the observer sees something in me that is rarely noticed, that any perceived element of nuance informs rather than persecutes, allowing my spirit and intuition to flex muscles of legitimacy. Within this perception, difference is acknowledged as talent and permitted to stand out and be seen. If you could reach back, arm angled far and deep into the history you've walked through, you may be able to pinpoint the exact moment where anxiety showed itself to you, how it acted on your body. My mother was in a car accident several years before the one that killed her. My father escorted her home after the accident, her jacket hanging off her shoulders. The white bow that she'd worn in her hair was in her right hand. When they told me what happened, I stood, murmuring concern. I poured her a glass of water. Then I returned to the television. In that same reach, arm hinging back like the capital letter "L," away from you, trying to remember when you first deemed yourself an artist, where would it take you? At the performance, my close friend Lee guided me, his hands on my hips, head nuzzling my shoulder. Our eyes rested on this white woman, watching her testify for a long while, even after the song was over. If my mother were an artist, if Willarena were an artist, she would have been Sharon Jones. I am stunned by my need to call my mother an artist, naïve to be surprised by the things that I may not know about her. This connection is risky: Willarena wasn't a soul singer. She was a schoolteacher, born in Nashville, Tennessee, to a World War II–veteran father and Cherokee mother, both the first in their families to raise children who were not enslaved. Sharon and Willarena shared a body—the trim box shape of Black women barely four and a half feet tall, with ivory smiles hovering above their shoulders. They were both women made of gold with a top lip curled under, meant for grooving to a favorite and familiar rhythm. Sharon and Willarena were women that danced because they had to and not because they wanted to. My mother's voice carried the abandon of a child—loud and off-key, often repetitive. Sing, baby, sing! she would tell me on long car trips as I murmured along to The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill. While working on Rikers Island as a security guard, Sharon would sing to the inmates before her [End Page 14] shift ended every night, as per their persistent request. Sharon's voice exclaimed a new life, a second life, one that allowed her to be center stage. There is another part of me that wants to consider artists as self-identified.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Erica N. Cardwell (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: