Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
AbstractBackground Jones fractures are common injuries in football players, particularly during the developmental years, and they often become problematic once they progress to complete fractures. Early detection of incomplete fractures can help prevent them from becoming complete fractures.Objective To assess the effectiveness of using ultrasound for screening incomplete Jones fractures.Participants The study involved 844 elite Japanese high school football players, totaling 1688 feet.Study Design Primary screening was conducted on the fifth metatarsal bases using a portable ultrasound device from two angles (lateral and basal). Positive screening criteria included the presence of periosteal focal thickening (Hump sign) and periosteal interruption (Beak sign) (see figure). Subsequently, a portable X-ray test was performed as a secondary screening.Risk Assessment and Main Outcomes The study aimed to identify asymptomatic players with incomplete Jones fractures and determine the positive predictive value (PPV) of primary ultrasound screening.Results Incomplete fractures were detected in 1.7% of the feet (29 out of 1688). During the primary screening, 3% of the feet (54 out of 1688) showed positive ultrasound findings, and 54% of those cases (29 out of 54) were confirmed as incomplete Jones fractures upon secondary X-ray examination. Consequently, the PPV of ultrasound screening was 54%.Conclusion This study identified 1.7% of asymptomatic incomplete fractures in young elite footballers. While X-ray tests are not ideal for all athletes due to radiation exposure concerns, using ultrasound scans for screening offers a less invasive and simpler alternative that can detect incomplete fractures. One limitation to consider is the possibility of false-negative results in ultrasound scans. As a next step, we aim to develop methods to enhance the accuracy of screening tests and expand their usage to protect more athletes.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
A 2024 study studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: