Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Reviewed by: Mychal Judge, OFM: Take Me Where You Want Me to Go by Francis DeBernardo Jason Steidl Jack Mychal Judge, OFM: Take Me Where You Want Me to Go. By Francis DeBernardo. Collegeville, MN: Liturgical Press, 2022. 176pp. $19.95. Father Mychal Judge, OFM, was 9/11's first identified fatality. After rushing into the burning North Tower of the World Trade Center to support victims and rescuers, he died when the South Tower collapsed. An image of firefighters carrying Judge's lifeless body became one of the most iconic from the tragic day. At his death, he was a beloved Franciscan priest, chaplain to the NYC Fire Department, and friend to politicos and the poor alike. Judge was also sober and gay. There are currently two biographies of Judge in the library of the small, Catholic university where I teach in Brooklyn. The first, a spiritual biography written by journalist Michael Ford within a year of Judge's death, called the Franciscan "an authentic American hero" and included quotes from then-revered figures such as Rudy Giuliani. The second, with tantalizing details published by columnist Michael Daly in 2008, confirmed rumors that Judge was not heterosexual. Today, the pages of both tomes are yellowing with age, Giuliani is a pariah within American politics, and same-sex marriage has been legal in New York State for more than a decade. But devotion to Judge has [End Page 81] only grown with time. Manhattan's West 31st Street bears his name; there is a statue of him in East Rutherford, New Jersey; and each year The Father Mychal Judge 9/11 Walk of Remembrance commemorates his heroism. With whispers of a formal canonization process in the works, many call him the "Saint of 9/11." Francis DeBernardo's recent work, Mychal Judge: Take Me Where You Want Me to Go, shows why the Franciscan's story remain relevant today. The book is part of Liturgical Press's People of God Series, which provides accessible and humanizing biographies of Catholics who shared a "credible and concrete witness of faith, hope, and love to people of our own day." DeBernardo's biography of Judge does not fail to inspire. In a stirring postscript, DeBernardo relates: "Throughout his lifetime, Judge had developed a particularly personal and intimate relationship with God. His ministry flowed from that relationship. His experience of God's goodness and grace inspired him to want to share these gifts with other people, to help them experience that too" (135). DeBernardo is an expert storyteller whose own background helps him better interpret the meaning of Judge's life. The longtime Executive Director of New Ways Ministry, "a Catholic outreach that educates and advocates for equity, inclusion, and justice for LGBTQ+ persons," DeBernardo, like Judge, hails from a large Catholic family in Brooklyn. As one who has been on the front lines of LGBTQ ministry and advocacy for decades, DeBernardo knows how radical it still is to claim that Judge, a priest active in the firefighter community, was gay—and that he could someday be formally recognized a saint. Mychal Judge, OFM blends biography and hagiography. While DeBernardo does not skirt around the challenges that Judge faced (his father died when he was six years old, he experienced spells of exhaustion and loneliness, he identified as an alcoholic, he had an intimate, though celibate, friendship with a New York City nurse), Judge always comes out a spiritual hero. DeBernardo admits that Judge's Franciscan brothers originally did not want him to be canonized a saint because "such a status would define Judge too narrowly and would even be an injustice to him" (132). But sainthood is exactly what emerges from the story of an earthy Brooklynite who overcame his weaknesses and never seemed to lack charity for anyone he met. By the end of the biography, I suspected that something about Judge may have been fundamentally different than everyone else. DeBernardo's repeated insistence that Judge's celibacy was part of his gay identity confirmed my intuition. Indeed, while Judge's celibacy may be historical truth, it will also be key for his canonization. Just as Mary serves as the saint of...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
J Jack (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: